视听及其交互效应对旅游者总体生活质量的影响研究--恢复性环境体验的中介作用

旅游科学 ›› 2021, Vol. 35 ›› Issue (4): 76-96.

视听及其交互效应对旅游者总体生活质量的影响研究--恢复性环境体验的中介作用

仇梦嫄^1,*, 杨加猛¹, 张捷²

1.南京林业大学经济管理学院,江苏南京 210037;
2.南京大学地理与海洋科学学院,江苏南京 210023

收稿日期:2021-04-02 修回日期:2021-07-10 出版日期:2021-08-30 发布日期:2021-09-18
通讯作者: ^*仇梦嫄（1988-）,女,博士,南京林业大学经济管理学院讲师,研究方向为旅游地理、农林经济管理,Email：qiumengyuan@njfu.edu.cn。
作者简介:杨加猛（1974-）,男,博士,南京林业大学经济管理学院教授,博导,研究方向为资源与环境管理、农林系统工程。张捷（1960-）,男,博士,南京大学地理与海洋科学学院教授,博导,研究方向为旅游地理、旅游景观。
基金资助:
国家自然科学基金青年项目“旅游地多维康复性景观综合效应与作用机制研究”（41901174）; 江苏省六大人才高峰高层次人才资助项目“江苏森林康养基地的游客消费意愿调查及业态发展策略”（NY-064）; 江苏省高校哲学社会科学研究项目“城市老年人康养旅游参与的限制因素及协商路径研究”（2019SJA0112）

A Study on Audio-visual Senses and the Impacts Audio-visual Interaction on Tourists’ Overall Quality of Life： The Mediating Role of Perceived Restorative Experiences

QIU Mengyuan^1,*, YANG Jiameng¹, ZHANG Jie²

1.College of Economics and Management, Nanjing Forestry University, Nanjing 210037, China;
2.School of Geography and Ocean Science, Nanjing University, Nanjing 210023, China

Received:2021-04-02 Revised:2021-07-10 Online:2021-08-30 Published:2021-09-18

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 健康是人类永恒的话题。“新冠”疫情的爆发使人们更加认识到身心健康的重要意义。通过旅游促进身心健康的恢复日益成为一种生活理念。旅游者恢复性环境体验也成为学界关注的热点。文章依据感官营销的分析框架,以视觉和听觉这两种人类高级感官形式为切入点,利用自然实验方法,选取西溪湿地旅游者为实验组,夫子庙-秦淮风光带旅游者为对照组,结合注意力恢复理论,探讨真实场景中的视听交互效应对旅游者恢复性环境体验和总体生活质量的作用路径。结果表明,视觉和听觉均是恢复性环境体验的重要来源,二者存在显著的交互效应：当旅游者的视觉评价较低时,与听觉评价较低的对照组相比,听觉评价较高的实验组更能够获得恢复性环境体验;而当视觉评价较高时,旅游者对目的地的听觉评价越高,恢复性环境体验越强烈。通过恢复性环境体验的中介作用,视觉与听觉的交互效应进一步延伸至旅游者总体生活质量。文章揭示了视听交互效应对旅游者健康与福祉的积极作用,拓展了旅游研究的范畴,为后疫情时代旅游目的地开发管理与营销提供科学依据。

关键词: 恢复性环境, 视觉, 听觉, 旅游体验, 总体生活质量, 自然实验法

Abstract: Health is an eternal topic of human concerns.The outbreak of COVID-19 has made people more aware of the importance of physical and mental health.Promoting the recovery of mental and physical health through tours has gradually become a healthy living attitude and tourists’ perceived restorative environment experiences has become a hotspot of the academic circle.Based on the framework of sensory marketing,this study conducted a quasi-experiment to explore the effects of tourists’ audio-visual interaction on their restorative experiences and overall quality of life by taking Xixi Wetland National Park in Hangzhou as the experimental group while the Confucius Temple-Qinhuai Scenic Area in Nanjing the control group.The results indicate：both seeing and hearing are higher hierarchy in sensory system and play very important roles in tourists’ restorative experiences; there are significant interaction effects between seeing and hearing;when visual evaluation is low,tourists with higher auditory evaluation could obtain more restorative experience and when it is higher,tourists with low auditory evaluation still could not obtain a restorative experience.What’s more,the audio-visual interaction could be further extended to tourists’ overall quality of life through the mediating effects of perceived restorative environment.This study reduced the research gap existing in the relationship between the multi-sensory and tourists’ health and well-being.The findings would help open up a new path to meet people’s needs for a better life,especially after the pandemic of COVID-19.

Key words: restorative environment, visual sense, auditory sense, tourist experience, overall quality of life, quasi-experiment

中图分类号:

F590

仇梦嫄, 杨加猛, 张捷. 视听及其交互效应对旅游者总体生活质量的影响研究--恢复性环境体验的中介作用[J]. 旅游科学, 2021, 35(4): 76-96.

QIU Mengyuan, YANG Jiameng, ZHANG Jie. A Study on Audio-visual Senses and the Impacts Audio-visual Interaction on Tourists’ Overall Quality of Life： The Mediating Role of Perceived Restorative Experiences[J]. TOURISM SCIENCE, 2021, 35(4): 76-96.

参考文献

[1] 陈钢华,奚望,2018.旅游度假区游客环境恢复性感知对满意度与游后行为意向的影响--以广东南昆山为例[J].旅游科学(4):17-30.
[2] 陈钢华,奚望,黄松山,等,2019.海滨旅游度假区游客环境和气候满意度对环境恢复性感知的影响[J].资源科学(3):430-440.
[3] 樊友猛,2020.旅游具身体验研究进展与展望[J].旅游科学(1):1-19.
[4] 郭永锐,张捷,卢韶婧,等,2014.旅游者恢复性环境感知的结构模型和感知差异[J].旅游学刊(2):93-102.
[5] 乐为,耿子文,郭本海,等,2019.酒店视觉舒适性影响因素研究--基于情绪视角[J].旅游科学 (6):33-45.
[6] 刘群阅,尤达,朱里莹,2017.游憩者场所依恋与恢复性知觉关系研究:以福州城市公园为例[J].资源科学(7):1303-1313.
[7] 路文彬,2006.论中国文化的听觉审美特质[J].中国文化研究(3):126-142.
[8] 吕兴洋,2018.目的地形象的感官营销思考[J].旅游学刊(3):7-8.
[9] 吕兴洋,徐海军,谭慧敏,等,2020.声音营销力:目的地歌曲对潜在旅游者的影响研究--以歌曲《成都》为例[J].旅游学刊(5):124-138.
[10] 麦克卢汉,2009.理解媒介--论人的延伸(文化传播译丛)[M].北京:商务印书馆:112-116.
[11] 仇梦嫄,王芳,沙润,等,2013.旅游者对旅游景区声景观属性的感知和满意度研究--以南京夫子庙-秦淮风光带为例[J].旅游学刊(1):54-61.
[12] 陶伟,王绍续,朱竑,2015.身体、身体观以及人文地理学对身体的研究[J].地理研究(6):1173-1187.
[13] 王宁,2020.准实验设计与比较个案研究[J].旅游学刊(12):3-4.
[14] 谢彦君,樊友猛,2017.身体视角下的旅游体验--基于徒步游记与访谈的扎根理论分析[J].人文地理(4):129-137.
[15] 徐红罡,王珂,2018.康复性流动视角下的健康与养生旅游研究展望[J].旅游学刊(6):1-16.
[16] 徐磊青,杨公侠,2002.环境心理学:环境、知觉和行为[M].上海:同济大学出版社:15-20.
[17] 张圆,2016.城市公共开放空间声景的恢复性效应研究[D].哈尔滨:哈尔滨工业大学.
[18] 周永广,张金金,周婷婷,2011.符号学视角下的旅游体验研究--西溪湿地的个案分析[J].人文地理(4):115-120.
[19] AGAPITO D,PINTO P,MENDES J,2017.Tourists’ memories,sensory impressions and loyalty:in loco and post-visit study in Southwest Portugal[J].Tourism management,58(2):108-118.
[20] ALETTA F,OBERMAN T,KANG J,2018.Associations between positive health-related effects and soundscapes perceptual constructs:a systematic review[J].International journal of environmental research and public health,15(11):2392-2398.
[21] ALVARSSON J J,WIENS S,NILSSON M E,2010.Stress recovery during exposure to nature sound and environmental noise[J].International journal of environmental research and public health,7(3):1036-1046.
[22] BARSALOU L W,2008.Grounded cognition[J].Annual review of psychology,59(3):617-645.
[23] BELL S L,FOLEY R,HOUGHTON F,et al.,2018.From therapeutic landscapes to healthy spaces,places and practices:a scoping review[J].Social science & medicine,196(2):123-130.
[24] BOWLER D E,BUYUNG-ALI L M,KNIGHT T M,et al.,2010.A systematic review of evidence for the added benefits to health of exposure to natural environments[J].BMC public health,10(1):1-10.
[25] CABE P A,PITTENGER J B,2000.Human sensitivity to acoustic information from vessel filling[J].Journal of experimental psychology:human perception and performance,26(1):313-324.
[26] CHEN G,HUANG S,ZHANG D,2017.Understanding Chinese vacationers’ perceived destination restorative qualities:cross-cultural validation of the perceived destination restorative qualities scale[J].Journal of travel & tourism marketing,34(8):1115-1127.
[27] COHEN E,COHEN S A,2012.Current sociological theories and issues in tourism[J].Annals of tourism research,39(4):2177-2202.
[28] DE COENSEL B,BOTTELDOORE D,2006.The quiet rural soundscape and how to characterize it[J].Acta acustica united with acustica,92(6):887-897.
[29] FRANCO L S,SHANAHAN D F,FULLER R A,2017.A review of the benefits of nature experiences:more than meets the eye[J].International journal of environmental research and public health,14(8):864-891.
[30] GALBRAITH J K,1958.The affluent society[M].US:Houghton Mifflin Harcourt:23-25.
[31] GESLER W M,1993.Therapeutic landscapes:theory and a case study of Epidauros,Greece[J].Environment and planning D:society and space,11(2):171-189.
[32] GOLDSTEIN E B,BROCKMOLE J,2016.Sensation and perception[M].US:Cengage Learning:26.
[33] GRAHN P,STIGSDOTTER U K,2010.The relation between perceived sensory dimensions of urban green space and stress restoration[J].Landscape and urban planning,94(3-4):264-275.
[34] GRINDE B,PATIL G G,2009.Biophilia:does visual contact with nature impact on health and well-being[J].International journal of environmental research and public health,6(9):2332-2343.
[35] HALL C M,2007.Tourism in Australia.Development,issues and change[M].5th ed.Australia:Pearson Education:251-253.
[36] HALL E T,1966.The hidden dimension[M].US:Doubleday:102-110.
[37] HAN K T,2018.A review of self-report scales on restoration and/or restorativeness in the natural environment[J].Journal of leisure research,49(3-5):151-176.
[38] HARTIG T,CATALANO R,ONG M,2007.Cold summer weather,constrained restoration,and the use of antidepressants in Sweden[J].Journal of environmental psychology,27(2):107-116.
[39] HARTIG T,MITCHELL R,DE VRIES S,et al.,2014.Nature and health[J].Annual review of public health,35(1):207-228.
[40] HERZOG T R,MAGUIRE P,NEBEL M B,2003.Assessing the restorative components of environments[J].Journal of environmental psychology,23(2):159-170.
[41] HIPP J A,OGUNSEITAN O A,2011.Effect of environmental conditions on perceived psychological restorativeness of coastal parks[J].Journal of environmental psychology,31(4):421-429.
[42] JAHNCKE H,ERIKSSON K,NAULA S,2015.The effects of auditive and visual settings on perceived restoration likelihood[J].Noise & health,17(74):1-10.
[43] JIANG J,ZHANG J,ZHENG C,et al.,2020.Natural soundscapes in nature-based tourism:leisure participation and perceived constraints[J].Current issues in tourism,23(4):485-499.
[44] JOYE Y,DEWITTE S,2018.Nature’s broken path to restoration:a critical look at Attention Restoration Theory[J].Journal of environmental psychology,59:1-8.
[45] KAPLAN R,KAPLAN S,1989.The experience of nature:a psychological perspective[M].Cambridge:Cambridge University Press:36-37.
[46] KELLER M C,FREDRICKSON B L,YBARRA O,et al.,2005.A warm heart and a clear head[J].Psychological science,16(9):724-731.
[47] KIM H,LEE S,UYSAL M,et al.,2015b.Nature-based tourism:motivation and subjective well-being[J].Journal of travel & tourism marketing,32(1):76-96.
[48] KIM H,WOO E,UYSAL M,2015a.Tourism experience and quality of life among elderly tourists[J].Tourism management,46:465-476.
[49] KJELLGREN A,BUHRKALL H,2010.A comparison of the restorative effect of a natural environment with that of a simulated natural environment[J].Journal of environmental psychology,30(4):464-472.
[50] KLER B K,2009.Tourism and restoration[M]//TRIBE J.Philosophical issues in tourism.Bristol:Channel View Publications:117-151.
[51] KPALAN S,1995.The restorative benefits of nature:toward an integrative framework[J].Journal of environmental psychology,15(3):169-182.
[52] KRISHNA A,2012.An integrative review of sensory marketing:engaging the senses to affect perception,judgment and behavior[J].Journal of consumer psychology,22(3):332-351.
[53] KRISHNA A,LWIN M O,MORRIN M,2010.Product scent and memory[J].Journal of consumer research,37(1):57-67.
[54] LEHTO X,KIRILLOVA K,LIH,et al.,2017.A cross-cultural validation of the perceived destination restorative qualities scale:the Chinese perspective[J].Asia Pacific journal of tourism research,22(3):329-343.
[55] LEHTO X Y,2013.Assessing the perceived restorative qualities of vacation destinations[J].Journal of travel research,52(3):325-339.
[56] LEHTO X Y,LEHTO M R,2019.Vacation as a public health resource:toward a wellness-centered tourism design approach[J].Journal of hospitality & tourism research,43(7):935-960.
[57] MILLER N P,2008.US national parks and management of park soundscapes:a review[J].Applied acoustics,69(2):77-92.
[58] MONTGOMERY D C,2017.Design and analysis of experiments[M].New Jersey:John Wiley & Sons:102-116.
[59] PALS R,STEGL,SIERO F W,2009.Development of the PRCQ:a measure of perceived restorative characteristics of zoo attractions[J].Journal of environmental psychology,29(4):441-449.
[60] PAN S,RYAN C,2009.Tourism sense‐making:the role of the senses and travel journalism[J].Journal of travel & tourism marketing,26(7):625-639.
[61] PARK B J,FURUYA K,KASETAIN T,et al.,2011.Relationship between psychological responses and physical environments in forest settings[J].Landscape and urban planning,102(1):24-32.
[62] PAYNE S R,2013.The production of a perceived restorativeness soundscape scale[J].Applied acoustics,74(2):255-263.
[63] PEARCE P L,2005.Tourist behavior:themes and conceptual schemes[M].Clevedon:Channel View Publications:26-27.
[64] PESCHARDT K K,STIGSDOTTER U K,2013.Associations between park characteristics and perceived restorativeness of small public urban green spaces[J].Landscape and urban planning,112(1):26-39.
[65] PHEASANT R J,FISHER M N,WATTS G R,et al.,2010.The importance of auditory-visual interaction in the construction of ‘tranquil space’[J].Journal of environmental psychology,30(4):501-509.
[66] QIU M,SHA J,SCOTT N,2021.Restoration of visitors through nature-based tourism:a systematic review,conceptual framework,and future research directions[J].International journal of environmental research and public health,18(5):2299-2308.
[67] QIU M,ZHANG J,ZHANG H,et al.,2018.Is looking always more important than listening in tourist experience?[J].Journal of travel & tourism marketing,35(7):869-881.
[68] SKAVRONSKAYA L,MOYLE B,SCOTT N,et al.,2020.The psychology of novelty in memorable tourism experiences[J].Current issues in tourism,23(21):2683-2698.
[69] STEVENSON M P,SCHIHAB T,BENSTSEN P,2018.Attention Restoration Theory II:a systematic review to clarify attention processes affected by exposure to natural environments[J].Journal of toxicology and environmental health,part B,21(4):227-268.
[70] TUAN Y,1979.Space and place:humanistic perspective[M]//GALE S,OLSSON G.Philosophy in geography.Berlin:Springer:387-427.
[71] TUAN Y,1990.Topophilia:a study of environmental perception,attitudes,and values[M].US:Columbia University Press:16-20.
[72] ULRICH R S,SIMONS R F,LOSITO B D,et al.,1991.Stress recovery during exposure to natural and urban environments[J].Journal of environmental psychology,11(3):201-230.
[73] UYSAL M,SIRGY M J,WOO E,et al.,2016.Quality Of Life (QOL) and well-being research in tourism[J].Tourism management,53(1):244-261.
[74] VAN DEN BERG A E,HARTIG T,STAATS H,2007.Preference for nature in urbanized societies:stress,restoration,and the pursuit of sustainability[J].Journal of social issues,63(1):79-96.
[75] WAITT G,DUFFY M,2010.Listening and tourism studies[J].Annals of tourism research,37(2):457-477.
[76] WATTS G R,PHEASANT R J,2015.Tranquillity in the Scottish Highlands and Dartmoor National Park:the importance of soundscapes and emotional factors[J].Applied acoustics,89:297-305.
[77] WOLF I D,AINSWORTH G B,CROWLEY J,2017.Transformative travel as a sustainable market niche for protected areas:a new development,marketing and conservation model[J].Journal of sustainable tourism,25(11):1650-1673.
[78] XIANG Z,GRETZEL U,2010.Role of social media in online travel information search[J].Tourism management,31(2):179-188.
[79] YANG Y,CHEN G,2020.In search of fresher air:the influence of relative air quality on vacationers’perceptions of destinations’ restorative qualities[J].International journal of tourism research,23(4):504-516.
[80] ZAHAVI D,2003.Husserl’s phenomenology[M].California:Stanford University Press:101-105.