旅游价值共创：研究回顾与未来展望

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 旅游价值共创通过整合游客和旅游服务提供者的资源,对提升游客体验和促进旅游服务创新都具有重要意义。文章通过对现有文献的系统梳理,对旅游价值共创的研究情境、概念界定、测量工具、影响因素、作用结果和研究转向进行了全面回顾和评述。在此基础上,从服务生态系统视角提出了包含行为和心理两方面的旅游价值共创概念,构建了旅游价值共创影响因素-共创过程-作用结果的研究框架;结合已有研究中出现的技术转向、整合转向和系统转向,识别出了现有研究的薄弱点,提出了未来的研究方向,以期构建旅游价值共创的理论体系,并为旅游营销和管理实践贡献知识。

关键词: 旅游价值共创, 研究情境, 共创机制, 研究转向, 研究综述

Abstract: Tourism value co-creation（TVCC） plays an important role in improving tourist experience and promoting service innovation by integrating the resources of tourist and tourism service provider.This paper made a systematic summary of the existing literature and reviewed TVCC from six aspects：research situation,concept definition,measurement tools,influencing factors,effect results and research turn.Based on this,it put forward the concept of TVCC with stakeholders regarded as the subjects of value co-creation from the perspective of service ecosystem,defined TVCC as a process in which tourism behavior subjects use their own resources to realize value through positive judgment of their own contribution and significance of cooperation and resource integration with other subjects through participation and interaction with the consideration of the behavior and psychological aspects,built rhe theoretical system of TVCC research according to the framework of influencing factors-co-creation process-co-creation results.And combined with the technology turn,integrality turn and system turn,the study identified the weak points of the research and proposed the future research direction.The authors expected that this paper would provide a systematic understanding of the theoretical framework of TVCC and contribute to the practice of tourism marketing and management.

Key words: tourism value co-creation, research situation, co-creation mechanism, research turn, systematic literature review

中图分类号:

F590

宋晓, 梁学成, 张新成, 刘文艺. 旅游价值共创：研究回顾与未来展望[J]. 旅游科学, 2022, 36(3): 36-57.

SONG Xiao, LIANG Xuecheng, ZHANG Xincheng, LIU Wenyi. Tourism Value Co-creation：Literature Review and Future Prospects[J]. TOURISM SCIENCE, 2022, 36(3): 36-57.

参考文献

[1] 范景明,张泽群,刘静,2020.价值共创视角下住宿类平台型企业商业模式演化分析——基于“小猪”的纵向案例研究[J].管理案例研究与评论(5):512-522.
[2] 胡有林,韩庆兰,2018.顾客参与对产品服务系统创新绩效的影响研究——基于产品与服务组合的调节分析[J].管理评论(12):76-88.
[3] 华成钢,白长虹,张辉,2020.共创还是共毁:移动信息技术对旅游体验价值的影响研究述评[J].外国经济与管理(2):137-152.
[4] 简兆权,令狐克睿,李雷,2016.价值共创研究的演进与展望——从“顾客体验”到“服务生态系统”视角[J].外国经济与管理(9):3-20.
[5] 简兆权,肖霄,2015.网络环境下的服务创新与价值共创:携程案例研究[J].管理工程学报(1):20-29.
[6] 江积海,李琴,2016.平台型商业模式创新中连接属性影响价值共创的内在机理——Airbnb的案例研究[J].管理评论(7):252-260.
[7] 李丽娟,2012.旅游体验价值共创影响机理研究——以北京香山公园为例[J].地理与地理信息科学(3):96-100.
[8] 李燕琴,陈灵飞,俞方圆,2020.基于价值共创的旅游营销运作模式与创新路径案例研究[J].管理学报(6):899-906.
[9] 刘欣,谢礼珊,黎冬梅,2021.旅游服务机器人拟人化对顾客价值共创意愿影响研究[J].旅游学刊(6):13-26.
[10] 盛建国,赵同庆,袁兴亮,2019.生态体育旅游的价值表现及开发策略[J].武汉体育学院学报(6):38-43.
[11] 韦鸣秋,白长虹,华成钢,2020.旅游公共服务价值共创:概念模型、驱动因素与行为过程——以杭州市社会资源国际访问点为例[J].旅游学刊(3):72-85.
[12] 谢礼珊,赵强生,马康,2019.旅游虚拟社区成员互动、感知利益和公民行为关系——基于价值共创的视角[J].旅游学刊(3):28-40.
[13] 张翠娟,徐虹,2019.参展商和专业观众参与展览会价值共创机理研究——基于结构方程模型的量化分析[J].旅游学刊(3):57-70.
[14] ALABAU-MONTOYA J,RUIZ-MOLINA M E,2020.Enhancing visitor experience with war heritage tourism through information and communication technologies:evidence from Spanish Civil War museums and sites[J].Journal of heritage tourism,15(5):500-510.
[15] ASSIOURAS I,SKOURTIS G,GIANNOPOULOS A,et al.,2019.Value co-creation and customer citizenship behavior[J].Annals of tourism research,78(2):1-26.
[16] BARNES S J,MATTSSON J,SØRENSEN F,et al.,2020.Measuring employee-tourist encounter experience value:a big data analytics approach[J].Expert systems with applications,154(13):1-13.
[17] BECK S,KENNING P,2015.The influence of retailers’ family firm image on new product acceptance:an empirical investigation in the German FMCG market[J].International journal of retail & distribution management,43(12):1126-1143.
[18] BUHALIS D,FOERSTE M,2015.SoCoMo marketing for travel and tourism:empowering co-creation of value[J].Journal of destination marketing & management,4(3):151-161.
[19] BUHALIS D,SINARTA Y,2019.Real-time co-creation and nowness service:lessons from tourism and hospitality[J].Journal of travel & tourism marketing,36(5):563-582.
[20] BUONINCONTRI P,MORVILLO A,OKUMUS F,et al.,2017.Managing the experience co-creation process in tourism destinations:empirical findings from Naples[J].Tourism management,62(1):264-277.
[21] BUSSER J A,SHULGA L V,2018.Co-created value:multidimensional scale and nomological network[J].Tourism management,65(3):69-86.
[22] CABIDDU F,LUI T W,PICCOLI G,2013.Managing value co-creation in the tourism industry[J].Annals of tourism research,42(5):86-107.
[23] CAMPOS A C,MENDES J,DO VALLE P O,et al.,2016.Co-creation experiences:attention and memorability[J].Journal of travel & tourism marketing,33(9):1309-1336.
[24] CAMPOS A C,MENDES J,DO VALLE P O,et al.,2017.Co-creating animal-based tourist experiences:attention,involvement and memorability[J].Tourism management,63(4):100-114.
[25] CANNAS R,ARGIOLAS G,CABIDDU F,2019.Fostering corporate sustainability in tourism management through social values within collective value co-creation processes[J].Journal of sustainable tourism,27(1):139-155.
[26] CASALÓ L V,FLAVIÁN C,GUINALÍU M,2010.Determinants of the intention to participate in firm-hosted online travel communities and effects on consumer behavioral intentions[J].Tourism management,31(6):898-911.
[27] CHEN J S,KERR D,CHOU C Y,et al.,2017.Business co-creation for service innovation in the hospitality and tourism industry[J].International journal of contemporary hospitality management,29(6):1522-1540.
[28] CHEN Z,KING B,SUNTIKUL W,2020.Co-creation of value for cultural festivals:behind the scenes in Macau[J].Tourism recreation research,27(6):1-15.
[29] CHOO H,PETRICK J F,2014.Social interactions and intentions to revisit for agritourism service encounters[J].Tourism management,40(5):372-381.
[30] ELETXIGERRA A,BARRUTIA J M,ECHEBARRIA C,2021.Tourist expertise and pre-travel value co-creation:task-related processes and beyond[J].Tourism management perspectives,37(9):1-11.
[31] FITZPATRICK M,DAVEY J,MULLER L,et al.,2013.Value-creating assets in tourism management:applying marketing’s service-dominant logic in the hotel industry[J].Tourism management,36(8):86-98.
[32] FONT X,ENGLISH R,GKRITZALI A,et al.,2021.Value co-creation in sustainable tourism:a service-dominant logic approach[J].Tourism management,82(8):1-13.
[33] FRIAS J D M,POLO P A I,RODRIGUEZ M M A,2017.The effect of value-creation on consumer-based destination brand equity[J].Journal of travel research,56(8):1011-1031.
[34] GONZÁLEZ-RODRÍGUEZ M R,DÍAZ-FERNÁNDEZ M C,BILGIHAN A,et al.,2021.UGC involvement,motivation and personality:comparison between China and Spain[J].Journal of destination marketing & management,19(3):1-14.
[35] GRISSEMANN U S,STOKBURGER-SAUER N E,2012.Customer co-creation of travel services:the role of company support and customer satisfaction with the co-creation performance[J].Tourism management,33(6):1483-1492.
[36] HOWELL R T,PCHELIN P,IYER R,2012.The preference for experiences over possessions:measurement and construct validation of the Experiential Buying Tendency Scale[J].The journal of positive psychology,7(1):57-71.
[37] HSIAO C,LEE Y H,CHEN W J,2015.The effect of servant leadership on customer value co-creation:a cross-level analysis of key mediating roles[J].Tourism management,49(3):45-57.
[38] IM J,QU H,2017.Drivers and resources of customer co-creation:a scenario-based case in the restaurant industry[J].International journal of hospitality management,64(4):31-40.
[39] IVANOV S H,WEBSTER C,BEREZINA K,2017.Adoption of robots and service automation by tourism and hospitality companies[J].Revista turismo & desenvolvimento,27(28):1501-1517.
[40] JÄRVI H,KERÄNEN J,RITALA P,et al.,2020.Value co-destruction in hotel services:exploring the misalignment of cognitive scripts among customers and providers[J].Tourism management,77(5):1-13.
[41] JIMÉNEZ-BARRETO J,CAMPO-MARTÍNEZ S,2018.Destination website quality,users’ attitudes and the willingness to participate in online co-creation experiences[J].European journal of management and business economics,27(1):26-41.
[42] KALLMUENZER A,PETERS M,BUHALIS D,2020.The role of family firm image perception in host-guest value co-creation of hospitality firms[J].Current issues in tourism,23(19):2410-2427.
[43] KASTENHOLZ E,EUSÉBIO C,CARNEIRO M J,2013.Studying factors influencing repeat visitation of cultural tourists[J].Journal of vacation marketing,19(4):343-358.
[44] KIROVA V,2020.Value co-creation and value co-destruction through interactive technology in tourism:the case of ‘La Cité du Vin’wine museum,Bordeaux,France[J].Current issues in tourism,15(3):1-14.
[45] KRACHT J,WANG Y,2010.Examining the tourism distribution channel:evolution and transformation[J].International journal of contemporary hospitality management,22(5):736-757.
[46] LEE G,LEE J,TUSSYADIAH I P,2017.The roles of perceived internal and external benefits and costs in innovation co-creation:lessons from Japan[J].Asia Pacific journal of tourism research,22(4):381-394.
[47] LEI S I,YE S,WANG D,et al.,2020.Engaging customers in value co-creation through mobile instant messaging in the tourism and hospitality industry[J].Journal of hospitality & tourism research,44(2):229-251.
[48] LI X,PETRICK J F,2008.Tourism marketing in an era of paradigm shift[J].Journal of travel research,46(3):235-244.
[49] LIN Z,CHEN Y,FILIERI R,2017.Resident-tourist value co-creation:the role of residents’ perceived tourism impacts and life satisfaction[J].Tourism management,61(6):436-442.
[50] LUONILA M,SUOMI K,LEPISTÖ T,2019.Unraveling mechanisms of value cocreation in festivals[J].Event management,23(1):41-60.
[51] MAGEE R,GILMORE A,2015.Heritage site management:from dark tourism to transformative service experience?[J].The service industries journal,35(15):898-917.
[52] MALONE S,MCKECHNIE S,TYNAN C,2018.Tourists’ emotions as a resource for customer value creation,cocreation,and destruction:a customer-grounded understanding[J].Journal of travel research,57(7):843-855.
[53] MARQUES L,BORBA C,2017.Co-creating the city:digital technology and creative tourism[J].Tourism management perspectives,24(2):86-93.
[54] MATHIS E F,KIM H L,UYSAL M,et al.,2016.The effect of co-creation experience on outcome variable[J].Annals of tourism research,57(3):62-75.
[55] MCLEAY F,LICHY J,MAJOR B,2019.Co-creation of the ski-chalet community experience scape[J].Tourism management,74(4):413-424.
[56] MINKIEWICZ J,EVANS J,BRIDSON K,2014.How do consumers co-create their experiences?An exploration in the heritage sector[J].Journal of marketing management,30(1):30-59.
[57] MOROSAN C,DEFRANCO A,2016.Co-creating value in hotels using mobile devices:a conceptual model with empirical validation[J].International journal of hospitality management,52(5):131-142.
[58] MOYLE B,CROY G,2007.Crowding and visitor satisfaction during the off-season:Port Campbell National Park[J].Annals of leisure research,10(3):518-531.
[59] NAVARRO S,GARZÓN D,ROIG-TIERNO N,2015.Co-creation in hotel-disable customer interactions[J].Journal of business research,68(7):1630-1634.
[60] NAVARRO S,LLINARES C,GARZON D,2016.Exploring the relationship between co-creation and satisfaction using QCA[J].Journal of business research,69(4):1336-1339.
[61] NEUHOFER B,BUHALIS D,LADKIN A,2012.Conceptualising technology enhanced destination experiences[J].Journal of destination marketing & management,1(2):36-46.
[62] NEUHOFER B,BUHALIS D,LADKIN A,2014.A typology of technology-enhanced tourism experiences[J].International journal of tourism research,16(4):340-350.
[63] O'DELL T,2007.Tourist experiences and academic junctures[J].Scandinavian journal of hospitality and tourism,7(1):34-45.
[64] OREFICE C,NYARKO N,2021.Sustainable value creation in event ecosystems-a business models perspective[J].Journal of sustainable tourism,29(11):1932-1947.
[65] PlÉ L,2017.Why do we need research on value co-destruction?[J].Journal of creating value,3(2):162-169.
[66] PRAHALAD C K,RAMASWAMY V,2004.Co-creation experiences:the next practice in value creation[J].Journal of interactive marketing,18(3):5-14.
[67] PREBENSEN N K,FOSS L,2011.Coping and co-creating in tourist experiences[J].International journal of tourism research,13(1):54-67.
[68] PREBENSEN N K,VITTERSØ J,DAHL T I,2013.Value co-creation significance of tourist resources[J].Annals of tourism research,42(2):240-261.
[69] PREBENSEN N K,WOO E,UYSAL M S,2014.Experience value:antecedents and consequences[J].Current issues in tourism,17(10):910-928.
[70] PREBENSEN N K,KIM H,UYSAL M,2016.Co-creation as moderator between the experience value and satisfaction relationship[J].Journal of travel research,55(7):934-945.
[71] PREBENSEN N K,XIE J,2017.Efficacy of co-creation and mastering on perceived value and satisfaction in tourists’ consumption[J].Tourism management,60(5):166-176.
[72] RANJAN K R,READ S,2016.Value co-creation:concept and measurement[J].Journal of the academy of marketing science,44(3):290-315.
[73] RATHER R A,HOLLEBEEK L D,ISLAM J U,2019.Tourism-based customer engagement:the construct,antecedents,and consequences[J].The service industries journal,39(7):519-540.
[74] REICHENBERGER I,2017.C2C value co-creation through social interactions in tourism[J].International journal of tourism research,19(6):629-638.
[75] RIHOVA I,BUHALIS D,GOUTHRO M B,et al.,2018.Customer-to-customer co-creation practices in tourism:lessons from customer-dominant logic[J].Tourism management,67(4):362-375.
[76] ROSS D,SAXENA G,2019.Participative co-creation of archaeological heritage:case insights on creative tourism in Alentejo,Portugal[J].Annals of tourism research,79(2):1-14.
[77] SANTOS-VIJANDE M L,LÓPEZ-SÁNCHEZ J Á,PACUAL-FERNANDEZ P,2018.Co-creation with clients of hotel services:the moderating role of top management support[J].Current issues in tourism,21(3):301-327.
[78] SHAW G,BAILEY A,WILLIAMS A,2011.Aspects of service-dominant logic and its implications for tourism management:examples from the hotel industry[J].Tourism management,32(2):207-214.
[79] SIGALA M,2018.Implementing social customer relationship management[J].International journal of contemporary hospitality management,30(7):2698-2726.
[80] SMALIUKIENE R,CHI-SHIUN L,SIZOVAITE I,2015.Consumer value co-creation in online business:the case of global travel services[J].Journal of business economics and management,16(2):325-339.
[81] STHAPIT E,BJÖRK P,2020.Towards a better understanding of interactive value formation:three value outcomes perspective[J].Current issues in tourism,23(6):693-706.
[82] STHAPIT E,BJÖRK P,2021.Interactive value formation:drivers and outcomes from Airbnb guests’ perspectives[J].Scandinavian journal of hospitality and tourism,21(2):129-147.
[83] TINSON J S,SAREN M A J,ROTH B E,2015.Exploring the role of dark tourism in the creation of national identity of young Americans[J].Journal of marketing management,31(7):856-880.
[84] TJANDRA N C,RIHOVA I,SNELL S,et al.,2020.Mega-events brand meaning co-creation:the Olympic case[J].Journal of product & brand management,30(1):58-73.
[85] TSENG F M,CHIANG L L L,2016.Why does customer co-creation improve new travel product performance?[J].Journal of business research,69(6):2309-2317.
[86] VARGO S L,LUSCH R F,2004.Evolving to a new dominant logic for marketing[J].Journal of marketing,68(1):1-17.
[87] VARGO S L,LUSCH R F,2016.Institutions and axioms:an extension and update of service-dominant logic[J].Journal of the academy of marketing science,44(1):5-23.
[88] WEI M,BAI C,LI C,et al.,2020.The effect of host-guest interaction in tourist co-creation in public services:evidence from Hangzhou[J].Asia Pacific journal of tourism research,25(4):457-472.
[89] WEILER B,BLACK R,2015.The changing face of the tour guide:one-way communicator to choreographer to co-creator of the tourist experience[J].Tourism recreation research,40(3):364-378.
[90] YANG F X,2016.Tourist co-created destination image[J].Journal of travel & tourism marketing,33(4):425-439.
[91] YI Y,GONG T,2013.Customer value co-creation behavior:scale development and validation[J].Journal of business research,66(9):1279-1284.
[92] ZHANG H,GORDON S,BUHALIS D,et al.,2018.Experience value co-creation on destination online platforms[J].Journal of travel research,57(8):1093-1107.
[93] ZHANG P,MENG F,SO K K F,2021.Co-creation experience in peer-to-peer accommodations:conceptualization and scale development[J].Journal of travel research,60(6):1333-1351.