《旅游法》出台、供给水平与旅游经济发展

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 加强法制建设,提升供给水平,是实现旅游经济长足发展的重要方式。文章将《中华人民共和国旅游法》视为一项准自然实验,以2008—2019年全国284个地级市为研究样本,采用双重差分模型系统考察法律制度建设对旅游经济发展的影响。实证结果表明：《旅游法》出台对人均旅游收入和人均旅游次数均具有正向促进作用,且对人均旅游收入的正向促进作用在资源禀赋较高、市场化程度较低、法治环境较好、腐败程度较低的城市更显著,对人均旅游次数的促进作用在资源禀赋较低、市场化程度较高、法治环境较好、腐败程度较低的城市更显著。文章通过进一步作用机制检验发现,法律制度建设推动旅游经济发展的核心逻辑是调整旅游业整体供给水平。具体表现为：《旅游法》出台通过保障劳动者各项权益,吸纳要素形成劳动力的规模效应;提高旅游业的市场竞争力,形成企业的聚集效应;赋予地方政府旅游发展规划权,充分发挥基础设施的正外部性,进而推动旅游经济发展。但总的来看,《旅游法》出台对旅游经济发展的积极作用重在增加人均旅游次数而非提升人均旅游收入,表明法制建设主要是通过刺激需求端,优化供给端,形成供给端和需求端响应机制进而推动旅游经济的长足发展。文章为更好地运用法律制度实现“依法治旅”和“依法兴旅”提供了理论基础和经验支持。

关键词: 旅游法, 供给水平, 双重差分, 旅游经济

Abstract: Strengthening the legal system construction and improving the level of supply are crucial ways to realize the rapid development of tourism economy.This paper regarded the Tourism Law of the People’s Republic of China as a quasi-natural experiment,sampled 284 prefecture-level cities in China from 2008 to 2019,used the dual difference model to systematically examine the impact of legal system construction on the high-quality development of tourism economy.The results show：（1） the enactment of Tourism Law has a positive effect on per capita tourism income and per capita tourism frequency,and its positive effect on per capita tourism income is more obvious in cities with higher resource endowment,lower marketization,better legal environment and lower degree of corruption;（2） the positive effect on per capita tourism frequency is more obvious in cities with lower resource endowment,higher marketization,better legal environment and lower degree of corruption.And a further mechanism test found that the core logic of legal system construction to promote tourism economic development is to adjust the overall supply level of tourism.Speacially, the path of implementation of Toursim Law to promote the developmet of tourism economy can be divided into three aspects.Firstly,Tourism Law has formed a scale effect of labor by protecting the rights and interests of workers.Secondly,its enactment can improve the market competitiveness of tourism enterprises,thus forming the aggragation effect of tourism enterprises.Thirdly,the legal system gives local government the right to plan for tourism development,which can help full play to the positive externalities of infrastructure.However,in general,the positive effects of the introduction of the Tourism Law on the development of tourism economy stress the increasing of the number of per capita tourism rather than per capita tourism income,indicating that the construction of the legal system is mainly to stimulate the demand side,and to optimize the supply side,and form the response mechanism of the supply side and the demand side to promote the rapid development of the tourism economy.This study provided theoretical basis and empirical support for the better use of the legal system to achieve managing travel by law and developing travel by law.

Key words: tourism law, supply level, difference-in-difference, tourism economic

中图分类号:

生延超, 李倩, 许玲玲. 《旅游法》出台、供给水平与旅游经济发展[J]. 旅游科学, 2023, 37(1): 133-155.

SHENG Yanchao, LI Qian, XU Lingling. Enactment of Tourism Law of the People’s Republic of China,Supply Level and High Quality Development of Tourism Economy[J]. TOURISM SCIENCE, 2023, 37(1): 133-155.

参考文献

[1] 陈志勇,陈思霞,2014.制度环境、地方政府投资冲动与财政预算软约束[J].经济研究(3):76-87.
[2] 程慧,徐琼,郭尧琦,2019.我国旅游资源开发与生态环境耦合协调发展的时空演变[J].经济地理(7):233-240.
[3] 丁振民,黄秀娟,2016.资本投入对中国森林公园旅游效率的影响研究[J].资源科学(7):1363-1372.
[4] 冯俏彬,贾康,2017.我国供给侧改革的背景、理论模型与实施路径[J].经济学动态(7):35-43.
[5] 郭家堂,骆品亮,2016.互联网对中国全要素生产率有促进作用吗?[J].管理世界(10):34-49.
[6] 郭建科,王绍博,王辉,等,2016.哈大高铁对东北城市旅游供需市场的空间效应研究——基于景点可达性的分析[J].地理科学进展(4):505-514.
[7] 韩峰,李玉双,2019.产业集聚、公共服务供给与城市规模扩张[J].经济研究(11):149-164.
[8] 韩卢敏,陆林,杨兴柱,2016.安徽省旅游政策变迁及其空间响应研究[J].地理科学(3):431-438.
[9] 何可,张俊飚,张露,等,2015.人际信任、制度信任与农民环境治理参与意愿——以农业废弃物资源化为例[J].管理世界(5):75-88.
[10] 黄震方,葛军莲,储少莹,2020.国家战略背景下旅游资源的理论内涵与科学问题[J].自然资源学报(7):1511-1524.
[11] 姜海宁,张文忠,余建辉,等,2020.山西资源型城市创新环境与产业结构转型空间耦合[J].自然资源学报(2):269-283.
[12] 孔令学,2013.浅谈《旅游法》对旅游者安全的全方位保护机制[J].旅游学刊(8):29-30.
[13] 李冬花,张晓瑶,陆林,等,2020.黄河流域高级别旅游景区空间分布特征及影响因素[J].经济地理(5):70-80.
[14] 李凤羽,王空,史永东,2021.腐败治理与城投债信用风险:基于中纪委地区巡视的分析[J].世界经济(10):157-178.
[15] 李光勤,胡志高,曹建华,2018.制度变迁与旅游经济增长——基于双重差分方法的“局改委”政策评估[J].旅游学刊(1):13-24.
[16] 林毅夫,沈艳,孙昂,2020.中国政府消费券政策的经济效应[J].经济研究(7):4-20.
[17] 刘贯春,叶永卫,张军,2021.社会保险缴费、企业流动性约束与稳就业——基于《社会保险法》实施的准自然实验[J].中国工业经济(5):152-169.
[18] 刘慧龙,吴联生,2014.制度环境、所有权性质与企业实际税率[J].管理世界(4):42-52.
[19] 刘瑞明,李林,亢延锟,等,2018.景点评选、政府公共服务供给与地区旅游经济发展[J].中国工业经济(2):118-136.
[20] 刘瑞明,毛宇,亢延锟,2020.制度松绑、市场活力激发与旅游经济发展——来自中国文化体制改革的证据[J].经济研究(1):115-131.
[21] 刘逸,李源,纪捷韩,2022.地理学视角下旅游安全事故成因研究——以我国居民赴泰旅游为例[J].世界地理研究(2):236-248.
[22] 刘震,杨勇,眭霞芸,2022.互联网发展、市场活力激发与旅游经济增长——基于空间溢出视角的分析[J].旅游科学(6):17-43.
[23] 卢现祥,朱巧玲,2007.新制度经济学[M].北京:北京大学出版社:113-115.
[24] 罗煜,何青,薛畅,2016.地区执法水平对中国区域金融发展的影响[J].经济研究(7):118-131.
[25] 马丽君,张家凤,2020.区域旅游发展空间差异变化对经济发展平衡性的影响[J].经济地理(1):197-203.
[26] 马晓龙,保继刚,2010.基于数据包络分析的中国主要城市旅游效率评价[J].资源科学(1):88-97.
[27] 马忠新,陶一桃,2018.制度供给、制度质量与城市发展不平衡——基于改革开放后288个城市发展差异的实证研究[J].财政研究(6):70-83.
[28] 戚东祥,2013.《旅游法》中“旅游服务合同”有关规定释义[J].旅游学刊(9):13-14.
[29] 钱雪松,方胜,2021.《物权法》出台、融资约束与民营企业投资效率——基于双重差分法的经验分析[J].经济学(季刊)(2):713-732.
[30] 渠涛,2013.对《旅游法》中有关民事法律关系问题的解读和思考[J].旅游学刊(9):14-16.
[31] 生延超,刘晴,2020.人力资本促进区域旅游经济效率的空间差异研究[J].地理科学(10):1710-1719.
[32] 孙盼盼,夏杰长,2016.地方政府的环境构建行为与旅游产业潜在增长——来自中国省际层面的实证认识[J].财贸经济(3):148-161.
[33] 汪德根,陈田,陆林,等,2015.区域旅游流空间结构的高铁效应及机理——以中国京沪高铁为例[J].地理学报(2):214-233.
[34] 王小鲁,樊纲,胡李鹏,2018.中国分省份市场化指数[M].北京:社会科学出版社:1-28.
[35] 王钊,李涛,杨山,2020.中国省际入境旅游集散优势度与旅游经济效率的空间关系[J].地理研究(4):892-906.
[36] 王兆峰,徐赛,2018.不同交通方式对旅游效率的影响与评价——以张家界为例[J].地理科学(7):1148-1155.
[37] 吴真松,谢朝武,郭志平,2014.《旅游法》与我国旅游行政治理体系的变革研究[J].旅游学刊(10):97-107.
[38] 夏杰长,裴文靖,2018.政策实效与产业效率损失:基于中国旅游产业的实证研究[J].中国社会科学院研究生院学报(4):41-49.
[39] 闫丽英,韩会然,陈婉婧,等,2014.北京市住宿业空间分布格局及影响因素研究[J].经济地理(1):94-101.
[40] 杨富斌,2013.《旅游法》的十大制度创新[J].法学杂志(10):19-28.
[41] 姚鹏,马志达,2022.非税自主权与部门结构升级:“竭泽而渔”还是“细水长流”?[J].财经研究(9):124-138.
[42] 于婷婷,左冰,宋玉祥,等,2020.中国旅游业发展对区域经济效率的影响——基于中国283个地级市的实证证据[J].地理研究(6):1357-1369.
[43] 曾博伟,魏小安,2018.旅游供给侧结构性改革[M].北京:中国旅游出版社.
[44] 张文显,2014.法治与国家治理现代化[J].中国法学(4):5-27.
[45] ASHENFELTER O C,CARD D,1984.Using the longitudinal structure of earnings to estimate the effect of training programs[J].Review of economics and statistics,67(4):648-660.
[46] BUTNARU G I,2015.The method of ethnographic and content analysis in determining development factors of economic and managerial tourism performance[J]. Procedia economics and finance,20:104-111.
[47] CANTONI D,CHEN Y,YANG D Y,et al.,2017.Curriculum and ideology[J].Journal of political economy,152(2):338-392.
[48] CASTELLANI V,SALA S,2010.Sustainable performance index for tourism policy development[J].Tourism management,31(6):871-880.
[49] CHEN Y,FAN Z,GU X,et al.,2020.Arrival of young talent:the send-down movement and rural education in China[J].American economic review,110(11):3393-3430.
[50] GARCIA F A,2014.A comparative study of the evolution of tourism policy in Spain and Portugal[J].Tourism management perspectives,11:34-50.
[51] JACOBSON L S,LALONDE R J,SULLIVAN D G,1993.Earning losses of displaced workers[J].The American economic review,83(4):685-709.
[52] KLAPPER L F,LOVE I,2004.Corporate governance, investor protection and performance in emerging markets[J].Journal of corporate finance,10(5):703-728.
[53] LE DANG H,NUBERG I,et al.,2014.Farmers’ perceived risks of climate change and influencing factors:a study in the Mekong Delta,Vietnam[J].Environmental management,54(2):331-345.
[54] LI P,LU Y,WANG J,2016.Does flattening government improve economic performance?Evidence from China[J].Journal of development economics,123(7):18-37.
[55] MARTÍNEZ R M,GALVÁN M O,LAFUENTE A M G,2014.Public policies and tourism marketing.An analysis of the competitiveness on tourism in Morelia,Mexico and Alcala de Henares,Spain[J].Procedia-social and behavioral sciences,148:146-152.
[56] MENG X,SIRIWARDANA M,PHAM T,2013.A CGE assessment of Singapore’s tourism policies[J].Tourism management,34(2):25-36.
[57] NORTH D C,1981.Structure and change in economic history[M].New York:Norton:3-13.
[58] NORTH D C,THOMAS R P,1973.The rise of the western world:a new economic history[M].Cambridge:Cambridge University Press:56-58.
[59] PACE L A,2016.How do tourism firms innovate for sustainable energy consumption?A capabilities perspective on the adoption of energy efficiency in tourism accommodation establishments[J]. Journal of cleaner production,111:409-420.
[60] SOKHANVAR A,2019.Does foreign direct investment accelerate tourism and economic growth within Europe?[J].Tourism management perspectives,29:86-96.
[61] SOLOW R M,1956.A contribution to the theory of economic growth[J].The quarterly journal of economics,70(1):65-94.
[62] WANG Y,BRAMWELL B,2012.Heritage protection and tourism development priorities in Hangzhou, China:a political economy and governance perspective[J].Tourism management,33(4):988-998.