酒店企业数字创新过程研究——基于南沙大酒店的叙事分析

旅游科学 ›› 2023, Vol. 37 ›› Issue (3): 86-105.

酒店企业数字创新过程研究——基于南沙大酒店的叙事分析

李美云^1,2,4, 利尚仁³, 谭红娟^2,*

1.中山大学管理学院,广东广州 510275;
2.广州新华学院管理学院,广东广州 510520;
3.广州番禺职业技术学院现代物流学院,广东广州 511483;
4.粤港澳应用数学中心数字与服务经济研究所,广东广州 510275

收稿日期:2022-08-08 修回日期:2023-05-18 出版日期:2023-06-30 发布日期:2023-07-11
通讯作者: ^*谭红娟（1986—）,女,广州新华学院管理学院讲师,研究方向为旅游产业可持续发展,E-mail：thj111111@126.com。
作者简介:李美云（1968—）,女,博士,中山大学管理学院副教授,研究方向为数字创新与服务经济,E-mail：mnslmy@sysu.edu.cn。利尚仁（1973—）,男,博士,广州番禺职业技术学院现代物流学院副教授,研究方向为数字创新、创业与区域发展。
基金资助:
国家自然科学基金项目“价值共创抑或共毁?——服务一线顾客-服务机器人互动前因后果研究”（72072187）; 广东省协同育人平台项目“国际化旅游‘三创’教育协同育人联盟”（2018XT001）; 广州市哲学社会科学“十三五”规划青年项目（2018GZQN52）; 广州新华学院科研基金项目（2019KYQN02）

A Study on the Digital Innovation Process of Hotel Enterprises —A Narrative Analysis Based on Nansha Grand Hotel

LI Meiyun^1,2,4, LI Shangjen³, TAN Hongjuan^2,*

1. School of Management, Sun Yat-Sen University, Guangzhou 510275, China;
2. School of Management, Guangzhou Xinhua University, Guangzhou 510520, China;
3. College of Modern Logistics, Guangzhou Panyu Polytechnic, Guangzhou 511483, China;
4. The Institute for Digital and Service Economy, Guangdong-Hongkong-Macau Center for Applied Mathematics, Guangzhou 510275, China

Received:2022-08-08 Revised:2023-05-18 Online:2023-06-30 Published:2023-07-11

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 在信息技术与产业融合发展的数字经济时代,数字创新成为组织转型升级、获取竞争优势的关键“新式武器”。然而,企业如何推进数字创新,又如何通过数字创新实现提质增效,获取竞争优势仍是战略迷思。文章通过对南沙大酒店数字创新故事的叙事探究,分析数字创新如何出现、形成和发展,并依此实现数字化转型升级的过程。研究结果表明：数字创新并不必然是由组织主动识别数字创新机会而战略性启动,也可能是由组织解决实际管理问题触发,并在持续的“问题-解决”进程中由下而上推进的;企业数字创新过程由数字创新启动、数字创新发展和数字创新应用3个动态非线性阶段组成;数字创新过程及其结果呈现复杂而动态的相互作用,这种不断迭代的创新过程导致数字产品、组织和商业模式创新的出现。研究结论既丰富了数字创新管理理论,也为传统服务企业数字创新实践提供了决策参考。

关键词: 数字创新过程, 数字创新启动, 叙事探究, 南沙大酒店

Abstract: In the era of digital economy of integrated digital technology and industrial development,digital innovation has become a crucial “new weapon” for organizations to transform and upgrade in order to gain competitive advantages.However,how to implement digital innovation as well as to escalate quality and achieve efficient improvement to the purpose of acquiring competitive advantages via digital innovation is still a strategic myth.This paper analyzed the ways that digital innovation are emerged,shaped and evolved in Nansha Grand Hotel in light with a narrative study of its digital innovation story,and how these processes make digital transformation and upgrading come to reality.The results show that （1） digital innovation is not necessary from organization’s initiative on strategic initiation triggered by identifying digital innovation opportunities,but may also be boosted by the organization’s solution to practical as well as managerial problems,and it gets evolved in a continuous “problem-solving” process;（2） the digital innovation process of an enterprise consists of three dynamic and non-linear phases：digital innovation initiation,digital innovation development,and digital innovation application;（3） the digital innovation process,as well as its outcomes,present a complex and dynamic mutual-interaction,and such a continuous iterative innovation process leads to the emergence of digital product,organizational,and innovative business models.The contributions not only enrich the digital innovation management theory,but also provide decision-making reference for the digital innovation practice of traditional service enterprises.

Key words: digital innovation process, digital innovation initiation, narrative analysis, Nansha Grand Hotel

中图分类号:

F719.2

李美云, 利尚仁, 谭红娟. 酒店企业数字创新过程研究——基于南沙大酒店的叙事分析[J]. 旅游科学, 2023, 37(3): 86-105.

LI Meiyun, LI Shangjen, TAN Hongjuan. A Study on the Digital Innovation Process of Hotel Enterprises —A Narrative Analysis Based on Nansha Grand Hotel[J]. TOURISM SCIENCE, 2023, 37(3): 86-105.

参考文献

[1] 蔡敦浩,施进忠,利尚仁,2010.叙说创业故事:察觉、学习与再诠释[J].组织与管理(TAOM)(2): 67-91.
[2] 韩文龙,2020.数字经济中的消费新内涵与消费力培育[J].福建师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版)(5):98-106;170.
[3] 井润田,孙璇,2021.实证主义vs.诠释主义:两种经典案例研究范式的比较与启示[J].管理世界(3):13;198-216.
[4] 刘洋,董久钰,魏江,2020.数字创新管理:理论框架与未来研究[J].管理世界(7):198-217;219.
[5] 刘志阳,林嵩,邢小强,2021.数字创新创业:研究新范式与新进展[J].研究与发展管理(1):1-11.
[6] 宋慧林,宋海岩,2013.国外旅游创新研究评述[J].旅游科学(2):1-13.
[7] 王一鸣,2017.中国经济新一轮动力转换与路径选择[J].管理世界(2):1-14.
[8] 王玉荣,段玉婷,卓苏凡,2022.工业互联网对企业数字创新的影响——基于倾向得分匹配的双重差分验证[J].科技进步与对策(8):89-98.
[9] 谢卫红,林培望,李忠顺,等,2020.数字化创新: 内涵特征、价值创造与展望[J].外国经济与管理(9):19-31.
[10] 熊伟,吴源媚,2018.智慧化对珠三角地区高星级酒店业绩的影响研究[J].旅游学刊(11):75-86.
[11] 张省,杨倩,2021.数字技术能力、商业模式创新与企业绩效[J].科技管理研究(10):144-151.
[12] ABRELL T,PIHLAJAMAA M,KANTO L,et al.,2016.The role of users and customers in digital innovation:insights from B2B manufacturing firms[J].Information & management,53(3):324-335.
[13] BHARADWAJ A,EL SAWY O A,PAVLOU P A,et al.,2013.Digital business strategy:toward a next generation of insights[J].MIS quarterly,37(2):471-482.
[14] BOLAND R J,LYYTINEN K,YOO Y,2007.Wakes of innovation in project networks:the case of digital 3-D representations in architecture,engineering,and construction[J].Organization science,18(4):547-747.
[15] BRUNER J,1986.Actual mind,possible worlds[M].Cambridge:Harvard University Press.
[16] BÜNTE F A,2015.The adoption of open innovation in the start-up evelopment process:a narrative inquiry on the mobile services industry in Sweden[D].Sweden:Jonpoking University.
[17] CIRIELLO R F,RICHTER A,SCHWABE G,2018.Digital innovation[J].Business & information systems engineering,60:563-569.
[18] CLANDININ D J,2006.Narrative inquiry:a methodology for studying lived experience[J].Research studies in music education,27:44-54.
[19] CONNELLY F M,CLANDININ D J,1990.Stories of experience and narrative inquiry[J].Educational researcher,19(5):2-14.
[20] DESOUZA K C,DOMBROWSKI C,AWAZU Y,et al.,2009.Crafting organizational innovation processes[J].Innovation: management,policy and practice,11(1):6-33.
[21] EDVARDSSON B,HAGLUND L,MATTSON J,1995.Analysis,planning,improvisation and control in the development of new services[J].International journal of service industry management,6(2):24-35.
[22] ETTLIE J E,ROSENTHAL S R,2011.Service versus manufacturing innovation[J].Journal of product innovation management,28(2):285-299.
[23] EWICK P,SILBEY S S,1995.Subversive stories and hegemonic tales:toward a sociology of narrative[J].Law & society review,29(2):197-226.
[24] FERREIRA J J,FERNANDES C I,FERREIRA F A,2019.To be or not to be digital,that is the question:firm innovation and performance[J].Journal of business research,101:583-590.
[25] FICHMAN R G,SANTOS B L D,ZHENG Z Q,2014.Digital innovation as a fundamental and powerful concept in the information systems curriculum[J].MIS quarterly,38(2):329-354.
[26] GARUD R,GEHMAN J,GIULIAN A P,2014.Conceptualizing entrepreneurial innovation:a narrative perspective[J].Research policy,43(7):1177-1188.
[27] GORAN J,LABERGE L,SRINIVASAN R,2017.Culture for a digital age[J].McKinsey quarterly,3(1):56-67.
[28] GROVER V,KOHLI R,2013.Revealing your hand:caveats in implementing digital business strategy[J].MIS quarterly,37(2):655-662.
[29] HAMILTON E,CRUZ A D,JACK S,2017.Re-framing the status of narrative in family business research:towards an understanding of families in business[J].Journal of family business strategy,8(1):3-12.
[30] HAN S H,LEE J,BO E,et al.,2021.Mobile technology adoption among hotels:managerial issues and opportunities[J].Tourism management perspectives,38:100811.
[31] HENFRIDSSON O,MATHIASSEN L,SCARBROUGH H,et al.,2018.Recombination in the open-ended value landscape of digital innovation[J].Information and organization,28(2):89-100.
[32] HENFRIDSSON O,MATHIASSEN L,SVAHN F,2014.Managing technological change in the digital age:the role of architectural frames[J].Journal of information technology,29(1):27-43.
[33] KOHLI R,MELVILLE N P,2019.Digital innovation:a review and synthesis[J].Information systems journal,29(1):200-223.
[34] LAM C,LAW R,2019.Readiness of upscale and luxury-branded hotels for digital transformation[J].International journal of hospitality management,79:60-69.
[35] LEE J,BERENTE N,2011.Digital innovation and the division of innovative labor:digital controls in the automotive industry[J].Organization science,23(5):1428-1447.
[36] LINCOLN Y S,1992.Sympathetic connections between qualitative methods and health research[J].Qualitative health research,2(4):375-391.
[37] LOKUGE S,SEDERA D,GROVER V,et al.,2019.Organizational readiness for digital innovation: development and empirical calibration of a construct[J].Information & management,56(3):445-461.
[38] LYNG H B,MACRAE C,GUISE V,et al.,2021.Balancing adaptation and innovation for resilience in healthcare—a metasynthesis of narratives[J].BMC health services research,21:1-13.
[39] LYYTINEN K,YOO Y,BOLAND R J,JR.,2016.Digital product innovation within four classes of innovation networks[J].Information systems journal,26(1):47-75.
[40] MELIÁN V,2016.The environment in disguise:insurgency and digital media in the southern cone[M]//HEIKE G.The environment in the age of the internet.UK:Oper Book Publishers:21-52.
[41] NAMBISAN S,LYYTINEN A,MAJCHRZAK,et al.,2017.Digital innovation management:reinventing innovation management research in a digital world[J].MIS quarterly,41(1):223-238.
[42] NAMBISAN S,WRIGHT M,FELDMAN M,2019.The digital transformation of innovation and entrepreneurship:progress,challenges and key themes[J].Research policy,48(8):103773.
[43] NYLÉN D,HOLMSTRÖM J,2015.Digital innovation strategy:a framework for diagnosing and improving digital product and service innovation[J].Business horizons,58(1):57-67.
[44] ORLIKOWSKI W J,2007.Sociomaterial practices:exploring technology at work[J].Organization studies,28(9):1435-1448.
[45] PAGANI M,2013.Digital business strategy and value creation:framing the dynamic cycle of control points[J].MIS quarterly,37(2):617-632.
[46] PENTLAND B T,1999.Building process theory with narrative:from description to explanation[J].Academy of management review,24(4):711-724.
[47] POLKINGHORNE D E,1995.Narrative configuration in qualitative analysis[J].International journal of qualitative studies in education,8(1):5-23.
[48] RIESSMAN C K,1993.Narrative analysis[M].CA: Sage.
[49] SAVIN-BADEN M,NIEKERK L,2007.Narrative inquiry:theory and practice[J].Journal of geography in higher education,31(3):459-472.
[50] STEYAERT C,1997.A qualitative methodology for process studies of entrepreneurship:creating local knowledge through stories[J].International studies of management and organization,27(3):13-33.
[51] STEYAERT C,2007.Entrepreneuring as a conceptual attractor?A review of process theories in 20 years of entrepreneurship studies[J].Entrepreneurship & regional development,19(6):453-477.
[52] WANG P,RAMILLER N C,2009.Community learning in information technology innovation[J].MIS quarterly,33(4):709-734.
[53] WESTERMAN G,2018.Your company doesn’t need a digital strategy[J].MIT sloan management review,59(3):1-5.
[54] YOO Y,BOLAND R J,LYYTINEN K,et al.,2012.Organizing for innovation in the digitized world[J].Organization science,23(5):1398-1408.
[55] YOO Y,HENFRIDSSON O,LYYTINEN K,2010.Research commentary—the new organizing logic of digital innovation:an agenda for information systems research[J].Information systems research,21(4):724-735.
[56] YUSSEN S R,OZCAN N M,1996.The development of knowledge about narratives[J].Educational psychology,2:1-68.