非对称视角下区域旅游经济差异形成机制研究——基于31个省（区、市）的清晰集定性比较分析

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 我国旅游经济长期存在明显的区域差异。然而,鲜有研究对影响因素相互作用形成区域旅游经济差异的机制进行分析。文章利用31个省（区、市）的旅游经济相关统计数据,采用清晰集定性比较分析（csQCA）进行非对称建模探讨区域旅游经济差异。结果表明：区域旅游经济差异的形成原因具有非对称性,高/低旅游经济收入存在不同的形成路径;大部分因素的作用效果会受到其他前因条件影响,表现出不对称的非线性效应;形成高旅游经济收入的核心条件是交通便利,原因主要表现为交通驱动,而导致低旅游经济收入的原因则是后天发展受限。文章不仅为区域旅游经济差异分析引入了新视角,有助于深入理解影响因素的复杂交互和非线性作用机制,还挖掘了基于区域的旅游发展模式,对旅游政策制定者具有重要实践指导。

关键词: 区域旅游经济差异, 非对称视角, 因果复杂性, 清晰集定性比较分析（csQCA）

Abstract: Distinctive regional disparity has long existed in China’s tourism economy.However,few researches dig into the mechanism of how influential factor interaction leads to such a disparity.With the statistical data of tourism economy in 31 provinces,this research discussed regional tourism economic disparity through csQCA asymmetric modeling,and uncovered the following results：（1） the causes of regional tourism economic disparity are asymmetric;（2） high/low tourist income have different formation approaches;（3） the functioning of most influential factors will be impacted by other antecedent conditions and presents an asymmetric non-linear effect;（4） convenient transportation is a core condition for high tourist income,and its antecedent configurations are mainly transport driven,while the antecedent configurations leading to low tourist income can be concluded as acquired development limited.This research not only introduced a new perspective for regional tourism economic disparity which enables in-depth comprehension of the complex interaction and non-linear function mechanism of the influential factors,but also explored a region-based tourism development model,therefore,it can offer significant practice guidance for tourism policymakers.

Key words: regional tourism economic disparity, asymmetric perspective, complex causality, crisp set qualitative comparative analysis

中图分类号:

F592.7

凌欢, 程励. 非对称视角下区域旅游经济差异形成机制研究——基于31个省（区、市）的清晰集定性比较分析[J]. 旅游科学, 2023, 37(4): 161-182.

LING Huan, CHENG Li. A Study of The Formation Mechanism of Regional Tourism Economic Disparity from Asymmetrical Perspective： Based on a Comparative Analysis of csQCA of the 31 Provinces[J]. TOURISM SCIENCE, 2023, 37(4): 161-182.

参考文献

[1] 敖荣军,韦燕生,2006.中国区域旅游发展差异影响因素研究——来自1990—2003年的经验数据检验[J].财经研究(3):32-43.
[2] 程聪,贾良定,2016.我国企业跨国并购驱动机制研究——基于清晰集的定性比较分析[J].南开管理评论(6):113-121.
[3] 程金龙,2018.中国区域旅游经济差异演变及主导因素分析[J].华东经济管理(12):56-62.
[4] 邓涛涛,王丹丹,刘璧如,2017.“资源诅咒”理论在旅游研究中的应用:综述与启示[J].旅游学刊(11):60-68.
[5] 杜运周,贾良定,2017.组态视角与定性比较分析(QCA):管理学研究的一条新道路[J].管理世界(6):155-167.
[6] 范香花,程励,2020.共享视角下乡村旅游社区居民旅游支持度的复杂性——基于fsQCA方法的分析[J].旅游学刊(4):36-50.
[7] 方叶林,黄震方,王芳,等,2018.中国大陆省际旅游效率时空演化及其俱乐部趋同研究[J].地理科学进展(10):1392-1404.
[8] 何良兴,张玉利,2020.创业意愿与行为:舒适区和可承担损失视角的清晰集定性比较分析[J].科学学与科学技术管理(8):26-42.
[9] 胡文海,程海峰,余菲菲,2015.皖南国际文化旅游示范区旅游经济差异分析研究[J].地理科学(11):1412-1418.
[10] 李正欢,蔡依良,段佳会,2019.利益冲突,制度安排与管理成效:基于QCA的国外国家公园社区管理研究[J].旅游科学(6):46-61.
[11] 凌欢,程励,赵晨月,等,2021.寓责于游:旅游者的遗产责任行为形成机制研究[J].旅游科学(2):30-51.
[12] 刘法建,方叶林,李东和,等,2015.省域旅游发展“资源诅咒”测度及其与区域经济的响应[J].华东经济管理(11):66-70.
[13] 刘佳,赵金金,2012.中国省域旅游经济发展的时空分异特征及其影响因素研究[J].经济问题探索(11):110-116.
[14] 马丽君,张家凤,2020.区域旅游发展空间差异变化对经济发展平衡性的影响[J].经济地理(1):197-203.
[15] 麻学锋,杨雪,2019.大湘西高级别景区时空分布特征及影响因素的空间异质性[J].自然资源学报(9):1902-1916.
[16] 谌飞龙,陈松,2023.创业叙事——资源获取逻辑下创业营销过程分析:基于创业路演的质性研究[J].南开管理评论(2):233-244.
[17] 孙盼盼,戴学锋,2014.中国区域旅游经济差异的空间统计分析[J].旅游科学(2):35-48.
[18] 汪德根,陈田,2011.中国旅游经济区域差异的空间分析[J].地理科学(5):528-536.
[19] 王俊,夏杰长,2018.中国省域旅游经济空间网络结构及其影响因素研究——基于QAP方法的考察[J].旅游学刊(9):13-25.
[20] 王兆峰,赵松松,2019.基于DEA-Malmquist模型的湖南省旅游产业效率时空动态演化及影响因素[J].长江流域资源与环境(8):1886-1897.
[21] 魏敏,李书昊,徐杰,2020.高质量发展背景下中国省际旅游竞争力再测度——基于PROMETHEE方法[J].商业研究(2):91-100.
[22] 温碧燕,梁明珠,2007.基于因素分析的区域旅游竞争力评价模型研究[J].旅游学刊(2):18-22.
[23] 夏鑫,何建民,刘嘉毅,2014.定性比较分析的研究逻辑——兼论其对经济管理学研究的启示[J].财经研究(10):97-107.
[24] 薛明月,王成新,赵金丽,等,2020.黄河流域旅游经济空间分异格局及影响因素[J].经济地理(4):19-27.
[25] 吴媛媛,宋玉祥,2018.中国旅游经济空间格局演变特征及其影响因素分析[J].地理科学(9):1491-1498.
[26] 谢风媛,2010.省域旅游业发展差异及对经济增长的影响研究[D].大连:大连理工大学.
[27] 闫佳祺,罗瑾琏,贾建锋,2018.组织情境因素联动效应对双元领导的影响——一项基于QCA技术的研究[J].科学学与科学技术管理(4):150-160.
[28] 杨洋洋,谢雪梅,2019.基于QCA的网络舆情热度影响因素构型分析[J].情报杂志(5):142-146.
[29] 杨勇,2007.中国省际旅游业竞争力分析——ARU结构与影响因素[J].山西财经大学学报(10):53-60.
[30] 杨勇,程玉,2019.改革开放40年旅游业发展的中国道路及其世界意义[J].旅游学刊(1):3-5.
[31] 叶茂,王兆峰,谭勇,2020.湘西地区交通与旅游发展的耦合协调特征与效应[J].经济地理(8):138-144.
[32] 张驰,郑晓杰,王凤彬,2017.定性比较分析法在管理学构型研究中的应用:述评与展望[J].外国经济与管理(4):68-83.
[33] 张梦,2006.区域旅游业竞争力:二维度分析模型[J].旅游科学(5):8-12.
[34] 张明,杜运周,2019.组织与管理研究中QCA方法的应用:定位,策略和方向[J].管理学报(9):1312-1323.
[35] 张圆刚,黄业坚,余向洋,2021.乡村旅游政策变迁影响路径的组态视角研究:基于黄山案例地的定性比较分析[J].地理科学进展(3):457-467.
[36] 赵磊,王佳,2015.中国旅游发展与经济增长——基于省际面板数据的协整分析[J].旅游科学(1):40-57.
[37] 朱海艳,孙根年,李君轶,2019.中国31省市国内旅游经济差异影响因素的空间计量研究[J].干旱区资源与环境(5):197-202.
[38] 左冰,2011.中国旅游经济增长因素及其贡献度分析[J].商业经济与管理(10):82-90.
[39] ANTONAKAKIS N,DRAGOUNI M,EECKELS B,et al.,2019.The tourism and economic growth enigma: examining an ambiguous relationship through multiple prisms[J].Journal of travel research,58(1):3-24.
[40] BAIDAL J,2003.Regional development policies:an assessment of their evolution and effects on the Spanish tourist model[J].Tourism management,24(6):655-663.
[41] BELESKA-SPASOVA E,LOYKULNANTA S,NGUYEN Q T K,2016.Firm-specific,national and regional competitive advantages:the case of emerging market MNEs-Thailand[J].Asian business & management,15(4):264-291.
[42] BELL R G,FILATOTCHEV I,AGUILERA R V,2014.Corporate governance and investors’ perceptions of foreign IPO value:an institutional perspective[J].Academy of management journal,57(1):301-320.
[43] BENKRAIEM R,LAHIANI A,MILOUDI A,et al.,2021.A new look at the tourism development and economic growth nexus:international evidence[J].Tourism economics,27(8):1707-1735.
[44] BOUKAS N,ZIAKAS V,2013.Impacts of the global economic crisis on Cyprus tourism and policy responses[J].International journal of tourism research,15(4):329-345.
[45] CAPONE F,BOIX R,2008.Sources of growth and competitiveness of local tourist production systems: an application to Italy (1991—2001)[J].Annals of regional science,42(1):209-224.
[46] DENG T,MA M,CAO J,2014.Tourism resource development and long-term economic growth:a resource curse hypothesis approach[J].Tourism economics,20(5):923-938.
[47] DUSA A,2007.User manual for the QCA(GUI) package in R[J].Journal of business research,60(5):576-586.
[48] ENILOV M,WANG Y,2022.Tourism and economic growth:multi-country evidence from mixed-frequency granger causality tests[J].Tourism economics,28(5):1216-1239.
[49] FISS P C,2011.Building better causal theories:a fuzzy set approach to typologies in organization research[J].Academy of management journal,54(2):393-420.
[50] FU H,XIAO X,LI Y,et al.,2022.Effects of entrepreneur passion on persuasion:study of venture capitalist funding decisions toward hospitality and tourism business plan presentation[J].Tourism management perspectives,44:101008.
[51] JANG S C,HAM S,2009.A double-hurdle analysis of travel expenditure:baby boomer seniors versus older seniors[J].Tourism management,30(3):372-380.
[52] JIN C,XU J,HUANG Z,2019.Spatiotemporal analysis of regional tourism development:a semiparametric geographically weighted regression model approach[J].Habitat international,87:1-10.
[53] KANG S,KIM J,NICHOLLS S,2014.National tourism policy and spatial patterns of domestic tourism in South Korea[J].Journal of travel research,53(6):791-804.
[54] KHADAROO J,SEETANAH B,2007.Transport infrastructure and tourism development[J].Annals of tourism research,34(4):1021-1032.
[55] KHADAROO J,SEETANAH B,2008.The role of transport infrastructure in international tourism development:a gravity model approach[J].Tourism management,29(5):831-840.
[56] KIM H J,CHEN M H,JANG S C,2006.Tourism expansion and economic development:the case of Taiwan[J].Tourism management,27(5):925-933.
[57] KOGUT B,RAGIN C C,2006.Exploring complexity when diversity is limited:institutional complementarity in theories of rule of law and national systems revisited[J].European management review,3(1):44-59.
[58] KUCEROVA J,MAKOVNIK T,2009.Regional tourism policy in Slovakia[J].E&M:ekonomie a management,12(1):6-13.
[59] LEE C C,CHANG C P,2008.Tourism development and economic growth:a closer look at panels[J].Tourism management,29(1):180-192.
[60] LI H,GOH C,QIU H,et al.,2015.Effect of tourism on balanced regional development:a dynamic panel data analysis in coastal and inland China[J].Asia Pacific journal of tourism research,20(6):694-713.
[61] LI S,BLAKE A,COOPER C,2010.China’s tourism in a global financial crisis:a computable general equilibrium approach[J].Current issues in tourism,13(5):435-453.
[62] LOHMANN G,PEARCE D G,2012.Tourism and transport relationships: the suppliers’ perspective in gateway destinations in New Zealand[J].Asia Pacific journal of tourism research,17(1):14-29.
[63] LOUCA C,2006.Income and expenditure in the tourism industry:time series evidence from Cyprus[J].Tourism economics,12(4):603-617.
[64] MAHMUDA S,SIGLER T,CORCORAN J,et al.,2022.Airbnb and micro-entrepreneurship in regional economies:lessons from Australia[J].Geographical research,60(2):269-285.
[65] MELIAN-GONZALEZ A,GARCIA-FALCON J M,2003.Competitive potential of tourism in destinations[J].Annals of tourism research,30(3):720-740.
[66] MÉRIDA A,GOLPE A A,2016.Tourism-led growth revisited for Spain:causality,business cycles and structural breaks[J].International journal of tourism research,18(1):39-51.
[67] NAUDÉ W A,SAAYMAN A,2005.Determinants of tourist arrivals in Africa:a panel data regression analysis[J].Tourism economics,11(3):365-391.
[68] OH C O,2005.The contribution of tourism development to economic growth in the Korean economy[J].Tourism management,26(1):39-44.
[69] O’HARE G,BARRETT H,1999.Regional inequalities in the Peruvian tourist industry[J].Geographical journal,165(1):47-61.
[70] OLYA H,MEHRAN J,2017.Modelling tourism expenditure using complexity theory[J].Journal of business research,75:147-158.
[71] ORDANINI A,PARASURAMAN A,RUBERA G,2014.When the recipe is more important than the ingredients:a qualitative comparative analysis (QCA) of service innovation configurations[J].Journal of service research,17(2):134-149.
[72] PAPPAS I O,KOUROUTHANASSIS P E,GIANNAKOS M N,et al.,2016.Explaining online shopping behavior with fsQCA:the role of cognitive and affective perceptions[J].Journal of business research,69(2):794-803.
[73] PAYNE J E,MERVAR A,2010.Research note:the tourism-growth nexus in Croatia[J].Tourism economics,16(4):1089-1094.
[74] PORTER M E,1990.The competitive advantage of nations[M].New York: The Free Press.
[75] PRIDEAUX B,2000.The role of the transport system in destination development[J].Tourism management,21(1):53-63.
[76] RAGIN C C,1987.The comparative method: moving beyond qualitative and quantitative strategies[M].Berkeley:University of California Press.
[77] RAGIN C C,2008.Redesigning social inquiry[M].Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
[78] RIHOUX B,ÁLAMOS-CONCHA P,BOL D,et al.,2013.From niche to mainstream method?A comprehensive mapping of QCA applications in journal articles from 1984 to 2011[J].Political research quarterly,66(1):175-184.
[79] RIHOUX B,RAGIN C C,2009.Configurational comparative methods:qualitative comparative analysis (QCA) and related techniques[M].London:Sage Publications.
[80] ROIG-TIERNO N,GONZALEZ-CRUZ T F,LLOPIS-MARTINEZ J,2017.An overview of qualitative comparative analysis:a bibliometric analysis[J].Journal of innovation & knowledge,2(1):15-23.
[81] ROSENTRAUB M S,JOO M,2009.Tourism and economic development:which investments produce gains for regions?[J].Tourism management,30(5):759-770.
[82] SALAZAR J P,CHANG S,GIRARD T C,2001.Visitor sharing among country attractions and hotels[J].Journal of hospitality & leisure marketing,8(1/2):33-43.
[83] SECKELMANN A,2002.Domestic tourism-a chance for regional development in Turkey?[J].Tourism management,23(1):85-92.
[84] SHI X,WANG Y,ZHUANG H,et al.,2021.Global hierarchy of maritime clusters:stability and reconstruction[J].Journal of transport geography,96:103205.
[85] SMITH S L J,1994.The tourism product[J].Annals of tourism research,21(3):582-595.
[86] TIAN F,YANG Y,JIANG L,2022.Spatial spillover of transport improvement on tourism growth[J].Tourism economics,28(5):1416-1432.
[87] VANKA G M,HEIJMAN J M,2013.The Kosovar wine cluster:a booster for regional development?[J].Agricultural economics,59(4):167-182.
[88] WANG K,YI J,WANG Y,2015.Research note:an analysis of the spatio-temporal disparities of inbound tourism development in China,1991—2010[J].Tourism economics,21(4):889-897.
[89] WEN J,SINHA C,2009.The spatial distribution of tourism in China:trends and impacts[J].Asia Pacific journal of tourism research,14(1):93-104.
[90] WOODSIDE A G,2013.Moving beyond multiple regression analysis to algorithms:calling for adoption of a paradigm shift from symmetric to asymmetric thinking in data analysis and crafting theory[J].Journal of business research,66(4):463-472.
[91] WOODSIDE A G,2016.The good practices manifesto:overcoming bad practices pervasive in current research in business[J].Journal of business research,69(2):365-381.
[92] YANG Y,2012.Agglomeration density and tourism development in China:an empirical research based on dynamic panel data model[J].Tourism management,33(6):1347-1359.
[93] YANG Y,FIK T,2014.Spatial effects in regional tourism growth[J].Annals of tourism research,46:144-162.