旅游体验视角下的记忆研究进展及启示

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 记忆是当代人文社会科学的重要研究对象,也与我们日常生活及社会发展紧密相关。近些年,记忆研究在旅游学中逐步得到关注,并成为旅游体验中的热点话题。文章梳理了旅游体验中记忆研究的基本概况和相关议题,从难忘的旅游体验、记忆的影响因素、记忆的作用、记忆的建构机理与模型等方面进行分析,以展现旅游体验视角下记忆研究的发展脉络和丰富意义。英文文献研究以心理学领域为主,以记忆中的情感话题为核心,形成了“难忘的旅游体验”这一特定概念,研究注重理论的实践指导价值。中文文献研究偏重于社会学领域,以社会文化领域的记忆研究理论为基础,以记忆的主客构建和外部环境因素为核心。文章通过中英文文献比较,归纳研究思路、方法和理论,总结差异形成共识,旨在反映旅游体验中记忆研究的基本态势,并为后续研究提供经验借鉴和思路启示。

关键词: 旅游体验, 记忆, 难忘的旅游体验, 集体记忆, 旅游体验记忆

Abstract: Memory is not only an essential research object in the humanities and social sciences today but also strongly tied to our daily lives and societal evolution.Memory studies have steadily gained interest in tourism studies in recent years and have become a popular topic in tourism experience.This paper summarized the basic overview and related issues of memory research in tourism experience,and analyzed the memorable tourism experience,memory influencing factors,memory role,memory construction mechanism,and memory model,to demonstrate the development context and rich significance of memory research from the perspective of tourism experience.The studies on English literature is mostly in the realm of psychology,with emotional subjects in memory as the center,and have established a specific idea of “memorable tourism experience,” with research focusing on the theoretical guiding value,while that on Chinese literature are mainly based on the main-object construction of memory and external environmental elements,which is founded on memory theory research in the field of social culture.It summarized the research ideas,methods,and theories through a comparison of Chinese and English research literature,as well as the differences to form a consensus,which aims to reflect the basic trend of memory research in tourism experience,and provide experience reference and inspiration for follow-up research.

Key words: tourism experience, memory, memorable tourism experiences（MTEs）, collective memory, tourism experience memory

中图分类号:

邓勇勇, 魏向东. 旅游体验视角下的记忆研究进展及启示[J]. 旅游科学, 2023, 37(5): 1-18.

DENG Yongyong, WEI Xiangdong. The Progress and Enlightenment of Memory Researches： A Tourism Experience Perspective[J]. TOURISM SCIENCE, 2023, 37(5): 1-18.

参考文献

[1] 阿斯曼,2015.文化记忆:早期高级文化中的文字、回忆和政治身份[M].金寿福,黄晓晨,译.北京:北京大学出版社.
[2] 白凯,康晓媛,王博林,2021.延安城市居民红色记忆的建构路径与代际差异[J].自然资源学报(7):1631-1646.
[3] 杜春燕,唐雪琼,成海,2020.聚焦“记忆”:旅游社会文化影响研究的口述史方法[J].华侨大学学报(哲学社会科学版)(1):36-44.
[4] 樊友猛,谢彦君,2015.记忆、展示与凝视:乡村文化遗产保护与旅游发展协同研究[J].旅游科学(1):11-24;87.
[5] 龚新琼,邢江,2020.海南国际旅游岛的主流媒体记忆与变迁——以《人民日报》为例[J].文化与传播(5):12-17.
[6] 郭云娇,王鄢然,罗秋菊,2021.旅游开发影响下民族社区文化记忆的代际传承——以西安回民街历史文化街区为例[J].地理研究(3):869-884.
[7] 哈布瓦赫,2002.论集体记忆[M].毕然,郭金华,译.上海:上海人民出版社.
[8] 韩丽军,王淑华,2020.海上邮轮旅游体验记忆与行为意向的关系研究[J].生产力研究(11):126-129;133;161.
[9] 韩丽军,王淑华,2021.旅游照片对旅游体验记忆与行为意向的影响[J].地域研究与开发(4):102-106.
[10] 何依,2005.城市记忆与文化传承——石浦老城保护规划与实施[J].城市规划(9):89-92.
[11] 胡润鸿,刑露雨,徐玉梅,2019.主题公园旅游体验记忆的结构维度与模型构建[J].云南地理环境研究(4):13-19.
[12] 黄维,梁璐,李凡,2016.文本、冲突与展演视角下的西方记忆地理研究评述[J].人文地理(4): 17-25.
[13] 康纳顿,2000.社会如何记忆[M].纳日碧力戈,译.上海:上海人民出版社.
[14] 李军,2021.禳灾文化记忆在乡村旅游中的价值重构——基于三个藏寨的案例研究[J].民族学刊(4):60-68;117.
[15] 利科,2018.记忆,历史,遗忘[M].李彦岑,陈颖,译.上海:华东师范大学出版社.
[16] 李彦辉,朱竑,2012.国外人文地理学关于记忆研究的进展与启示[J].人文地理(1):11-15;28.
[17] 黎耀奇,关巧玉,2018.旅游怀旧:研究现状与展望[J].旅游学刊(2):105-116.
[18] 刘沛林,2015.新型城镇化建设中“留住乡愁”的理论与实践探索[J].地理研究(7):1205-1212.
[19] 陆明明,2020.旅游认同的双向转换进化与生态系统构建[J].旅游学刊(11):7-9.
[20] 马天,谢彦君,2015.旅游体验的社会建构:一个系统论的分析[J].旅游学刊(8):96-106.
[21] 麦夏兰,兰婕,田蕾,2014.记忆、物质性与旅游[J].西南民族大学学报(人文社会科学版)(9):1-7.
[22] 诺拉,2020.记忆之场:法国国民意识的文化社会史[M].黄红艳,等,译.南京:南京大学出版社.
[23] 潘澜,林璧属,王昆欣,2016.探索旅游体验记忆的影响因素——中国旅游情景下的研究[J].旅游学刊(1):49-56.
[24] 钱立成,琅翮翱,2015.社会记忆研究:西方脉络、中国图景与方法实践[J].社会学研究(6):215-237;246.
[25] 钱莉莉,李罕梁,季靖,2020.黑色旅游地游客集体记忆建构及其对行为意愿的影响——以“5·12”汶川地震北川老县城遗址为例[J].旅游导刊(6):59-74.
[26] 钱莉莉,张捷,郑春晖,等,2015.地理学视角下的集体记忆研究综述[J].人文地理(6):7-12.
[27] 桑森垚,2016.探索赴韩中国游客体验记忆形成过程中的关键要素和记忆偏差[J].旅游论坛(4):33-39;94.
[28] 沈雨婕,王媛,许鑫,等,2020.华亭初见记:文化记忆视角下的上海旅游形象感知[J].图书馆论坛(10):59-65.
[29] 宋玉,黄剑锋,2019.国内外乡村记忆地理研究进展与展望[J].世界地理研究(6):166-177.
[30] 孙九霞,周一,2015.遗产旅游地居民的地方认同——“碉乡”符号、记忆与空间[J].地理研究(12):2381-2394.
[31] 孙信茹,王东林,2021.作为记忆的地点——数码时代中社交媒体与地点互构研究[J].新闻与传播研究(5):66-84;127.
[32] 唐弘久,张捷,2013.旅游地居民对于“5·12”大地震集体记忆的信息建构特征——以九寨沟旅游地区为例[J].长江流域资源与环境(5):669-677.
[33] 汪芳,吕舟,张兵,等,2017.迁移中的记忆与乡愁:城乡记忆的演变机制和空间逻辑[J].地理研究(1):3-25.
[34] 王新歌,虞虎,陈田,2019.旅游视角下的地域乡愁文化元素识别及维度构建——以古徽州文化旅游区为例[J].资源科学(12):2237-2247.
[35] 文彤,刘璐,2019.博物馆文化展演与城市记忆活化传承 ——基于旅游留言档案的文本分析[J].热带地理(2):267-277.
[36] 吴仁献,2020.个体旅游记忆:结构维度、再现过程与行为影响研究[D].泉州:华侨大学.
[37] 吴炆佳,孙九霞,2018.旅游地理视角下记忆研究的进展与启示[J].人文地理(6):18-27.
[38] 许春晓,成锦,2017.旅游目的地记忆图谱市场细分法构建[J].经济地理(2):187-192.
[39] 徐克帅,2016.红色旅游和社会记忆[J].旅游学刊(3):35-42.
[40] 薛熙明,覃璇,唐雪琼,2012.旅游对恩施土家族居民民族认同感的影响——基于个人生活史的视角[J].旅游学刊(3):27-35.
[41] 殷紫燕,黄安民,2019.文化创意旅游街区游客参与对重游意愿的作用机制研究——基于旅游体验及记忆的中介模型[J].资源开发与市场(8):1087-1092.
[42] 袁振杰,马凌,2020.行走的记忆,记忆的行走:旅游中体验与地方认同[J].旅游学刊(11):5-7.
[43] 曾诗晴,谢彦君,史艳荣,2021.时光轴里的旅游体验——历史文化街区日常生活的集体记忆表征及景观化凝视[J].旅游学刊(2):70-79.
[44] 章锦河,2014.社会记忆与旅游规划的创意[J].旅游学刊(5):12-13.
[45] 郑春晖,张捷,钱莉莉,2016.黑色旅游者行为意向差异研究——以侵华日军南京大屠杀遇难同胞纪念馆为例[J].资源科学(9):1663-1671.
[46] 朱兴涛,张传运,2019.集体记忆重塑:乡村旅游市场培育的现实路径——以查干湖旅游市场为例[J].东北师大学报(哲学社会科学版).DOI:10.16164/j.cnki.22-1062/c.2023.01.019.
[47] AGAPITO D,PINTO P,MENDES J,2017.Tourists’ memories,sensory impressions and loyalty:in loco and post-visit study in Southwest Portugal[J].Tourism management,58:108-118.
[48] ARNOULD E,PRICE L,1993.River magic:extraordinary experience and the extended service encounter[J].Journal of consumer research,20(1):24-45.
[49] BALLANTYNE R,PACKER J,SUTHERLAND L A,2011.Visitors’ memories of wildlife tourism:implications for the design of powerful interpretive experiences[J].Tourism management,32(4):770-779.
[50] BAREITHER C,2021.Difficult heritage and digital media:‘selfie culture’ and emotional practices at the memorial to the murdered Jews of Europe[J].International journal of heritage studies,27(1):57-72.
[51] BIGNE E,FUENTES-MEDINA M L,MORINI-MARRERO S,2020.Memorable tourist experiences versus ordinary tourist experiences analysed through user-generated content[J].Journal of hospitality and tourism management,45:309-318.
[52] BOORSTIN D,1964.The image:a guide to pseudo-events in America[M].New York:Vintage books.
[53] BRAKUS J J,SCHMITT B H,ZARANTONELLO L,2009.Brand experience:what is it?How is it measured?Does it affect loyalty?[J].Journal of marketing,73(3):52-68.
[54] BRAUN-LATOUR K A,GRINLEY M J,LOFTUS E F,2006.Tourist memory distortion[J].Journal of travel research,44(4):360-367.
[55] CAO Y,LI X,DIPIETRO R,et al.,2019.The creation of memorable dining experiences:formative index construction[J].International journal of hospitality management,82:308-317.
[56] CHANDRALAL L,RINDFLFLEISH J,VALENZUELA F,2015.An application of travel blog narratives to explore memorable tourism experiences[J].Asia Pacific journal of tourism research,20(6):680-693.
[57] CHEN H,RAHMAN I,2018.Cultural tourism:an analysis of engagement,cultural contact,memorable tourism experience and destination loyalty[J].Tourism management perspectives,26:153-163.
[58] COELHO M D F,GOSLING M D S,ALMEIDA A S A D,2018.Tourism experiences:core processes of memorable trips[J].Journal of hospitality and tourism management,37:11-22.
[59] COHEN E,1979.A phenomenology of tourist experience[J].Sociology,13(2):179-201.
[60] COHEN S A,COHEN E,2019.New directions in the sociology of tourism[J].Current issues in tourism,22(2):153-172.
[61] FARMAKI A,2021.Memory and forgetfulness in tourism crisis research[J].Tourism management,83:104210.
[62] FRIDGEN J D,1984.Environmental psychology and tourism[J].Annals of tourism research,11(1): 19-39.
[63] GRABURN N H H,1983.The anthropology of tourism[J].Annals of tourism research,10(1):9-33.
[64] KASTENHOLZ E,CARNEIRO M J,MARQUES C P,et al.,2018.The dimensions of rural tourism experience:impacts on arousal,memory,and satisfaction[J].Journal of travel & tourism marketing,35(2):189-201.
[65] KERSTETTER D,CHO M H,2004.Prior knowledge,credibility and information search[J].Annals of tourism research,31(4):961-985.
[66] KIM H,KOO C,CHUNG N,2021.The role of mobility apps in memorable tourism experiences of Korean tourists:stress-coping theory perspective[J].Journal of hospitality and tourism management,49:548-557.
[67] KIM J H,2009.Development of a scale to measure memorable tourism experiences[D].Indiana,US:Indiana University.
[68] KIM J H,2010.Determining the factors affecting the memorable nature of travel experiences[J].Journal of travel & tourism marketing,27(8):780-796.
[69] KIM J H,2014.The antecedents of memorable tourism experiences:the development of a scale to measure the destination attributes associated with memorable experiences[J].Tourism management,44:34-45.
[70] KIM J H,RITCHIE J R B,MCCORMICK B,2012a.Development of a scale to measure memorable tourism experiences[J].Journal of travel research,51(1):12-25.
[71] KIM J H,RITCHIE J R B,TUNG V W S,2010.The effect of memorable experience on behavioral intentions in tourism:a structural equation modeling approach[J].Tourism analysis,15(6):637-648.
[72] KIM K,HALLAB Z,KIM J N,2012b.The moderating effect of travel experience in a destination on the relationship between the destination image and the intention to revisit[J].Journal of hospitality marketing & management,21(5):486-505.
[73] LARSEN S,JENSSEN D,2004.The school trip:traveling with,not to or from[J].Scandinavian journal of hospitality and tourism,4:43-57.
[74] LEHTO X Y,O’LEARY J T,MORRISON A M,2004.The effect of prior experience on vacation behavior[J].Annals of tourism research,31(4):801-818.
[75] MACCANNELL D,1973.Staged authenticity:arrangements of social space in tourist settings[J].American journal of sociology,79(3):589-603.
[76] MARSCHALL S,2012.Tourism and memory[J].Annals of tourism research,39(4):2216-2219.
[77] MARTINI A,BUDA D M,2020.Dark tourism and affect:framing places of death and disaster[J].Current issues in tourism,23(6):679-692.
[78] MELON M P A,HERRERA C F,SARASA R G,2021.Analysis of antecedents and consequences of memorable tourist experiences(MTEs):a Spanish case study[J].Journal of vacation marketing,27(3):346-360.
[79] MÜGGENBURG H,2021.Beyond the limits of memory?The reliability of retrospective data in travel research[J].Transportation research part a:policy and practice,145:302-318.
[80] NAWIJN J,BIRAN A,2019.Negative emotions in tourism:a meaningful analysis[J].Current issues in tourism,22(19):2386-2398.
[81] NORA P,1989.Between memory and history:les lieux de mémoire[J].Representations,26:7-24.
[82] OH H,FIORE A M,JEOUNG M,2007.Measuring experience economy concepts:tourism applications[J].Journal of travel research,46(2):119-132.
[83] OTTO J,RITCHIE J R B,1995.Exploring the quality of the service experience:a theoretical and empirical analysis[J].Advances in services marketing and management,4(1):37-61.
[84] PARK S,SANTOS C A,2016.Exploring the tourist experience:a sequential approach[J].Journal of travel research,56(1):16-27.
[85] PASTOR D,KENT A J,2020.Transformative landscapes:liminality and visitors’ emotional experiences at German memorial sites[J].Tourism geographies,22(2):250-272.
[86] PEARCE P L,LEE U I,2005.Developing the travel career approach to tourist motivation[J].Journal of travel research,43(3):226-237.
[87] RIVERA D E,FA M C,VILLAR A S,2019.Delightful tourism experiences:a cognitive or affective matter?[J].Tourism management perspectives,32:100569.
[88] RYAN C,1997.The tourist experience:a new introduction[M].London:Cassell.
[89] SANTOS V,SOUSA B,RAMOS P,et al.,2022.Emotions and involvement in tourism settings[J].Current issues in tourism,25(10):1526-1531.
[90] SCHEER M,2012.Are emotions a kind of practice(and is that what makes them have a history)?A Bourdieuian approach to understanding emotion[J].History and theory,51(2):193-220.
[91] SELLICK M C,2004.Discovery,connection,nostalgia:key travel motives within the senior market[J].Journal of travel & tourism marketing,17(1):55-71.
[92] SERVIDIO R,RUFFOLO I,2016.Exploring the relationship between emotions and memorable tourism experiences through narratives[J].Tourism management perspectives,20:151-160.
[93] STERCHELE D,2020.Memorable tourism experiences and their consequences:an interaction ritual(IR) theory approach[J].Annals of tourism research,81:102847.
[94] STHAPIT E,2017.Exploring tourists’ memorable food experiences:a study of visitors to Santa’s official hometown[J].Anatolia,28(3):404-421.
[95] STHAPIT E,JIMÉNEZ-BARRETO J,2018.Exploring tourists’ memorable hospitality experiences:an Airbnb perspective[J].Tourism management perspectives,28:83-92.
[96] STONE M J,MIGACZ S,STHAPIT E,2022.Connections between culinary tourism experiences and memory[J].Journal of hospitality & tourism research,46(4):797-807.
[97] TUCKER H,2016.Empathy and tourism:limits and possibilities[J].Annals of tourism research,57:31-43.
[98] TUNG V W S,RITCHIE J R B,2011a.Exploring the essence of memorable tourism experiences[J].Annals of tourism research,38(4):1367-1386.
[99] TUNG V W S,RITCHIE J R B,2011b.Investigating the memorable experiences of the senior travel market:an examination of the reminiscence bump[J].Journal of travel & tourism marketing,28(3):331-343.
[100] WANG N,1999.Rethinking authenticity in tourism experience[J].Annals of tourism research,26(2):349-370.
[101] WILLIAMS L,BUOYE A,KEININGHAM T L,et al.,2020.The practitioners’ path to customer loyalty:memorable experiences or frictionless experiences?[J].Journal of retailing and consumer services,57:102215.
[102] WINTER J,2001.The memory boom in contemporary historical studies[J].Raritan,21(1):52-66.
[103] WIRTZ D,KRUGER J,SCOLLON C N,et al.,2003.What to do on spring break?The role of predicted,on-line,and remembered experience in future choice[J].Psychological science,14(5):520-524.
[104] ZHANG H M,WU Y,BUHALIS D,2018.A model of perceived image,memorable tourism experiences and revisit intention[J].Journal of destination marketing & management,8:326-336.
[105] ZHENG Y Y,WEI W,LINE N,et al.,2021.Integrating the tourist gaze with the social servicescape:implications for creating memorable theme park experiences[J].International journal of hospitality management,93:102782.
[106] ZIMMERMAN C A,KELLEY C M,2010.“I’ll remember this！” Effects of emotionality on memory predictions versus memory performance[J].Journal of memory and language,62(3):240-253.