基于选择实验和陈述属性不出席的旅游资源非市场价值研究——以“长岛渔号”国家级非物质文化遗产为例

旅游科学 ›› 2024, Vol. 38 ›› Issue (10): 62-81.

基于选择实验和陈述属性不出席的旅游资源非市场价值研究——以“长岛渔号”国家级非物质文化遗产为例

肖建红^1,2,*, 李万紫¹, 王飞¹, 王敏¹

1.青岛大学商学院,山东青岛 266071;
2.青岛大学经略海洋研究中心,山东青岛 266071

收稿日期:2023-10-23 修回日期:2024-09-19 出版日期:2024-10-30 发布日期:2024-12-04
作者简介:肖建红（1979—）,男,博士,青岛大学商学院和青岛大学经略海洋研究中心教授,研究方向为海洋旅游,E-mail：xiaojian_hong@163.com。李万紫（2000—）,女,青岛大学商学院硕士生。王飞（1996—）,女,青岛大学商学院硕士生。王敏（1981—）,女,博士,青岛大学商学院讲师,研究方向为旅游项目管理。
基金资助:
山东省自然科学基金项目“基于CVM的群岛旅游资源非使用价值评估嵌入效应：山东庙岛群岛典型案例研究”（ZR2020MG043）; 山东省社会科学规划项目“非物质文化遗产活态化保护与传承发展的经济价值研究”（23CGLJ11）; 国家社会科学基金项目“基于条件价值评估法的群岛旅游资源非使用价值评估嵌入效应问题研究”（17BGL247）

A Study of Non-Market Value of Tourism Resources Based on Choice Experiment and Stated Attribute Non-Attendance：A Case Study of Changdao Fishermen’s Work Songs as a National Intangible Cultural Heritage

XIAO Jianhong^1,2,*, LI Wanzi¹, WANG Fei¹, WANG Min¹

1. Business College, Qingdao University, Qingdao 266071, China;
2. Research Center for Marine Management Strategy, Qingdao University, Qingdao 266071, China

Received:2023-10-23 Revised:2024-09-19 Online:2024-10-30 Published:2024-12-04

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 选择实验（Choice Experiment,CE）是旅游资源非市场价值评估的核心方法,属性不出席（Attribute Non-Attendance,ANA）是CE的重要偏差。文章以“长岛渔号”国家级非物质文化遗产旅游资源为研究对象,首先,通过文献梳理、半结构式访谈和焦点小组讨论,确定了"长岛渔号"的表演、体验、宣传、传承、精神和一次性捐款6个属性及属性分级,并采用游客面对面调查的方式收集CE数据。其次,运用带误差项的随机参数logit模型进行数据分析,通过将陈述ANA信息纳入数据分析中,对比考虑陈述ANA和不考虑陈述ANA的游客对"长岛渔号"属性的偏好和支付意愿结果的差异。结果表明：（1）仅有28.59%的受访者在做选择时考虑了所有属性,大部分受访者至少忽略了一个属性,其中,一次性捐款是最容易被忽略的属性。（2）与不考虑陈述ANA的带误差项随机参数logit模型结果相比,考虑陈述ANA的模型没有改变“长岛渔号”属性“传承>表演>宣传>体验>精神”的重要性顺序,但得到了略优的拟合优度和更低的支付意愿估计值。同时,两个模型结果在受访者属性偏好方面具有较高的一致性和稳健性。研究建议：ANA对支付意愿的估计结果产生了重要影响,旅游资源非市场价值CE研究中应将ANA作为一个重要问题进行考虑。

关键词: 旅游资源, 非市场价值, 选择实验, 陈述属性不出席, 非物质文化遗产, 长岛渔号

Abstract: Choice Experiment (CE) stands as a fundamental method for assessing the non-market value of tourism resources. Within CE, an essential consideration is attribute non-attendance (ANA), which may introduce bias. This study focused on the national intangible cultural heritage tourism resource of Changdao Fishermen's Work Songs. First of all, through literature review, semi-structured interviews with various stakeholders of Changdao Fishermen's Work Songs, and focus group discussions, six attributes and attribute hierarchies were identified: performance, experience, advertisement, inheritance, spirit, and one-time donation of Changdao Fishermen's Work Songs. CE data were collected through face-to-face surveys of tourists. Secondly, random parametric logit with error component (RPL-EC) model was employed for data analysis. By incorporating stated ANA information into the data analysis, this study compared the preference and willingness to pay (WTP) for Changdao Fishermen's Work Songs between respondents who considered stated ANA and those who did not. The findings revealed that: (1) Only 28.59% of respondents considered all attributes when making choices. A majority of respondents tended to overlook at least one attribute, with one-time donation being the most frequently disregarded attribute. (2) Compared with the model without ANA, the model incorporating stated ANA did not alter the order of attribute importance, which remained as follows: "inheritance>performance>advertisement>experience>spirit". Nevertheless, it yielded slightly better goodness-of-fit and lower WTP estimates. Meanwhile, both models exhibited a high degree of consistency and robustness regarding respondents' attribute preferences. In light of these findings, it is recommended that ANA should be considered as an important factor in CE studies assessing the non-market value of tourism resources, as it significantly impacts the estimation of WTP.

Key words: tourism resources, non-market value, Choice Experiments(CE), Attribute Non-Attendance (ANA), intangible cultural heritage, Changdao Fishermen's Work Songs

中图分类号:

F590.31

肖建红, 李万紫, 王飞, 王敏. 基于选择实验和陈述属性不出席的旅游资源非市场价值研究——以“长岛渔号”国家级非物质文化遗产为例[J]. 旅游科学, 2024, 38(10): 62-81.

XIAO Jianhong, LI Wanzi, WANG Fei, WANG Min. A Study of Non-Market Value of Tourism Resources Based on Choice Experiment and Stated Attribute Non-Attendance：A Case Study of Changdao Fishermen’s Work Songs as a National Intangible Cultural Heritage[J]. TOURISM SCIENCE, 2024, 38(10): 62-81.

参考文献

[1] 白军飞,罗津京,张彩萍,2019.消费者对可追溯牛奶的支付意愿:基于属性不在场的选择实验[J].中国食物与营养(8):57-62.
[2] 程秋旺,黄巧龙,于赟,等,2020.福建省湿地自然保护区游憩资源价值评价——基于选择实验法的分析[J].林业经济(2):38-47.
[3] 高杨,赵端阳,于丽丽,2019.家庭农场绿色防控技术政策偏好与补偿意愿[J].资源科学(10):1837-1848.
[4] 黄和平,王智鹏,林文凯,2020.风景名胜区旅游资源价值损害评估——以三清山巨蟒峰为例[J].旅游学刊(9):26-40.
[5] 李宝强,封萍萍,2017.大珠山风景区旅游资源非使用价值评估[J].中国人口·资源与环境(11):208-211.
[6] 李京梅,刘铁鹰,2010.基于旅行费用法和意愿调查法的青岛滨海游憩资源价值评估[J].旅游科学(4):49-59.
[7] 王朋薇,钟林生,梅荣,等,2016.审议货币评估法和条件价值法的比较和应用——以达赉湖自然保护区为例[J].旅游科学(6):12-21;53.
[8] 烟台市文化和旅游局,2008.非遗项目长岛渔号[EB/OL].(2008-06-07)[2024-09-26].https://www.ytta.cn/intangible/1038015194422312960.
[9] 烟台市文化和旅游局,2021.提档升级优化品牌,加快旅游产业转型发展[EB/OL].(2021-01-22) [2024-09-26].https://www.ytta.cn/information/1152983524333060096.
[10] AHI J C,KIPPERBERG G,2020.Attribute non-attendance in environmental discrete choice experiments:the impact of including an employment attribute[J].Marine resource economics,35(3):201-218.
[11] ALEMU M H,MORKBAK M R,OLSEN S B,et al.,2013.Attending to the reasons for attribute non-attendance in choice experiments[J].Environmental and resource economics,54(3):333-359.
[12] BALBONTIN C,HENSHER D A,2020.Identifying the role of stated process strategies in business location decisions[J].Transportation research part e-logistics and transportation review,141: 102028.
[13] BALCOMBE K,BURTON M,RIGBY D,2011.Skew and attribute non-attendance within the Bayesian mixed logit model[J].Journal of environmental economics and management,62(3):446-461.
[14] BIR C,CUMMINS A M,WIDMAR N O,et al.,2018.Willingness to pay estimates informing agribusiness decision making:a cautionary tale[J].International food and agribusiness management review,21(7):865-882.
[15] BRIDGES J F P,HAUBER A B,MARSHALL D,et al.,2011.Conjoint analysis applications in health-a checklist:a report of the ISPOR good research practices for conjoint analysis task force[J].Value in health,14(4):403-413.
[16] CAPUTO V,NAYGA R M,SCARPA R,2013.Food miles or carbon emissions?Exploring labelling preference for food transport footprint with a stated choice study[J].Australian journal of agricultural and resource economics,57(4):465-482.
[17] CAPUTO V,VAN LOO E J,SCARPA R,et al.,2018.Comparing serial,and choice task stated and inferred attribute non-attendance methods in food choice experiments[J].Journal of agricultural economics,69(1):35-57.
[18] CARLSSON F,KATARIA M,LAMPI E,2010.Dealing with ignored attributes in choice experiments on valuation of Sweden's environmental quality objectives[J].Environmental and resource economics,47(1):65-89.
[19] COLOMBO S,CHRISTIE M,HANLEY N,2013.What are the consequences of ignoring attributes in choice experiments?Implications for ecosystem service valuation[J].Ecological economics,96:25-35.
[20] DURAN R,FARIZO B A,VAZQUEZ M X,2015.Conservation of maritime cultural heritage:a discrete choice experiment in a European Atlantic region[J].Marine policy,51:356-365.
[21] ERDEM S,CAMPBELL D,HOLE A R,2015.Accounting for attribute-level non-attendance in a health choice experiment:does it matter?[J].Health economics,24(7):773-789.
[22] GONÇALVES T,LOURENÇO-GOMES L,PINTO L,2020.Dealing with ignored attributes through an inferred approach in wine choice experiments[J].Journal of behavioral and experimental economics,87:101551.
[23] HARRISON J L,NAUMENKO A,WHITEHEAD J C,2021.Attribute nonattendance and citizen preferences for ecosystem-based fisheries management:the case of Atlantic menhaden[J].Contemporary economic policy,39(2):310-324.
[24] HEIDENREICH S,WATSON V,RYAN M,et al.,2018.Decision heuristic or preference?Attribute non-attendance in discrete choice problems[J].Health economics,27(1):157-171.
[25] HENSHER D A,ROSE J,GREENE W H,2005.The implications on willingness to pay of respondents ignoring specific attributes[J].Transportation,32(3):203-222.
[26] HINDSLEY P,LANDRY C E,MORGAN O A,2020.Incorporating certainty and attribute non-attendance in choice experiments:an application to valuation of coastal habitat[J].Marine resource economics,35(3):241-262.
[27] HINDSLEY P,MORGAN O A,WHITEHEAD J C,2023.Combining revealed and stated preference models for artificial reef siting:a study in the Florida Keys[J].Journal of environmental management,325:116481.
[28] HOLE A R,2011.A discrete choice model with endogenous attribute attendance[J].Economics letters,110(3):203-205.
[29] HOYOS D,2010.The state of the art of environmental valuation with discrete choice experiments[J].Ecological economics,69(8):1595-1603.
[30] JOHNSTON R J,BOYLE K J,ADAMOWICZ W,et al.,2017.Contemporary guidance for stated preference studies[J].Journal of the association of environmental and resource economists,4(2):319-405.
[31] JOURDAIN D,VIVITHKEYOONVONG S,2017.Valuation of ecosystem services provided by irrigated rice agriculture in Thailand:a choice experiment considering attribute nonattendance[J].Agricultural economics,48(5):655-667.
[32] KEHLBACHER A,BALCOMBE K,BENNETT R,2013.Stated attribute non-attendance in successive choice experiments[J].Journal of agricultural economics,64(3):693-706.
[33] KING S,FRASER I,O'HANLEY J R,2016.Benefits transfer and the aquatic environment:an investigation into the context of fish passage improvement[J].Journal of environmental management,183:1079-1087.
[34] KRAGT M E,2013.Stated and inferred attribute attendance models:a comparison with environmental choice experiments[J].Journal of agricultural economics,64(3):719-736.
[35] KRINSKY I,ROBB A L,1986.On approximating the statistical properties of elasticities[J].The review of economics and statistics,68(4):715-719.
[36] LACHER R G,OH C O,JODICE L W,et al.,2013.The role of heritage and cultural elements in coastal tourism destination preferences[J].Journal of travel research,52(4):534-546.
[37] LAGARDE M,2013.Investigating attribute non-attendance and its consequences in choice experiments with latent class models[J].Health economics,22(5):554-567.
[38] LANCASTER K,1966.A new approach to consumer theory[J].Journal of political economy,74(2):132-157.
[39] LEE M K,YOO S H,2016.Public's willingness to pay for a marina port in Korea:a contingent valuation study[J].Ocean and coastal management,119:119-127.
[40] LUSK J L,ROOSEN J,FOX J A,2003.Demand for beef from cattle administered growth hormones or fed genetically modified corn:a comparison of consumers in France,Germany,the United Kingdom,and the United States[J].American journal of agricultural economics,85(1):16-29.
[41] MOHANTY S K,BALCOMBE K,BENNETT R,et al.,2019.Attribute specific impacts of stated non-attendance in choice experiments[J].Journal of agricultural economics,70(3):686-704.
[42] MORKBAK M R,OLSEN S B,CAMPBELL D,2014.Behavioral implications of providing real incentives in stated choice experiments[J].Journal of economic psychology,45:102-116.
[43] NOTARO S,DE SALVO M,RAFFAELLI R,2022.Estimating willingness to pay for Alpine pastures:a discrete choice experiment accounting for attribute non-attendance[J].Sustainability,14(7):4093.
[44] ORME B K,2010.Getting started with conjoint analysis:strategies for product design and price research (2nd ed.)[M].Madison,WI:Research Publishers.
[45] ORTEGA D L,WANG H H,OLYNK N J,et al.,2012.Chinese consumers' demand for food safety attributes:a push for government and industry regulations[J].American journal of agricultural economics,94(2):489-495.
[46] OYINBO O,CHAMBERLIN J,MAERTENS M,2020.Design of digital agricultural extension tools:perspectives from extension agents of Nigeria[J].Journal of agricultural economics,71(3):798-815.
[47] OYINBO O,CHAMBERLIN J,VANLAUWE B,et al.,2019.Farmers' preferences for high-input agriculture supported by site-specific extension services:evidence from a choice experiment in Nigeria[J].Agricultural systems,173:12-26.
[48] POULOS C,JOHNSON F R,KRISHNARAJAH G,et al.,2015.Pediatricians' preferences for infant meningococcal vaccination[J].Value in health,18(1):67-77.
[49] ROGERS A A,2013.Public and expert preference divergence:evidence from a choice experiment of marine reserves in Australia[J].Land economics,89(2):346-370.
[50] SAAYMAN M,KRUGELL W F,SAAYMAN A,2016.Willingness to pay:who are the cheap talkers?[J].Annals of tourism research,56:96-111.
[51] SCARPA R,THIENE M,MARANGON F,2008.Using flexible taste distributions to value collective reputation for environmentally friendly production methods[J].Canadian journal of agricultural economics,56(2):145-162.
[52] SCARPA R,WILLIS K G,ACUTT M,2007.Valuing externalities from water supply:status quo,choice complexity and individual random effects in panel kernel logit analysis of choice experiments[J].Journal of environmental planning and management,50(4):449-466.
[53] SNOWBALL J D,WILLIS K G,2006.Building cultural capital:transforming the South African National Arts Festival[J].South African journal of economics,74(1):20-33.
[54] SNOWBALL J D,WILLIS K G,2011.Interview versus self-completion questionnaires in discrete choice experiments[J].Applied economics letters,18(16):1521-1525.
[55] TRAIN K E,2003.Discrete choice methods with simulation[M].Cambridge,UK:Cambridge University Press.
[56] VAN LOO E J,NAYGA R M,CAMPBELL D,et al.,2018.Using eye tracking to account for attribute non-attendance in choice experiments[J].European review of agricultural economics,45(3):333-365.
[57] VAN ZANTEN B T,KOETSE M J,VERBURG P H,2016.Economic valuation at all cost?The role of the price attribute in a land scape preference study[J].Ecosystem services,22:289-296.
[58] YAO R T,WALLACE L,2024.A systematic review of non-market ecosystem service values for biosecurity protection[J].Ecosystem services,67:101628.