旅游科学 ›› 2024, Vol. 38 ›› Issue (5): 1-22.
• • 下一篇
李志飞1,2, 敖昆砚1,2, 李江敏3,*
收稿日期:
2023-08-29
修回日期:
2024-04-18
出版日期:
2024-05-30
发布日期:
2024-06-11
通讯作者:
李江敏*(1976—),女,博士,中国地质大学(武汉)经济管理学院教授,博导,研究方向为文化旅游与遗产旅游,E-mail:413932000@qq.com。
作者简介:
李志飞(1976—),男,博士,湖北大学旅游学院教授,博导,研究方向为旅游行为、乡村旅游、文化旅游,E-mail:1372272021@qq.com。敖昆砚,女,湖北大学旅游学院硕士生。
基金资助:
LI Zhifei1,2, AO Kunyan1,2, LI Jiangmin3,*
Received:
2023-08-29
Revised:
2024-04-18
Online:
2024-05-30
Published:
2024-06-11
摘要: 乡村旅游地的社区居民公民行为在加强社区治理成果、塑造优质的游客体验及展现良好的乡村精神文明风貌中有着重要作用。文章利用社会交换理论,以肇兴侗寨为案例地,以乡村旅游地居民为研究对象,面向社区和游客分别建立两条影响社区居民公民行为的传导路径,探讨理性因素(旅游利益感知)如何通过非理性因素(社区认同和居民感恩)影响乡村旅游地的社区居民公民行为。结果表明:(1) 居民的旅游利益感知能够促进居民的社区认同、对游客的感恩和乡村旅游地的社区居民公民行为;(2) 居民的社区认同和对游客的感恩对乡村旅游地的社区居民公民行为具有正向影响;(3) 居民的社区认同和对游客的感恩在旅游利益感知和社区居民公民行为之间起部分中介作用。文章对乡村旅游目的地的营销管理和社区治理等方面具有一定的理论意义和实践意义。
中图分类号:
李志飞, 敖昆砚, 李江敏. 因利感恩?旅游利益感知对乡村旅游地社区居民公民行为的影响机制[J]. 旅游科学, 2024, 38(5): 1-22.
LI Zhifei, AO Kunyan, LI Jiangmin. Grateful for the Benefits?The Mechanism of Perceived Benefits of Tourism on Community Citizenship Behavior in Rural Tourism[J]. TOURISM SCIENCE, 2024, 38(5): 1-22.
[1] 蔡定昆,许小帆,2023.乡村旅游提高农村居民幸福感了吗?——基于海南省博纵村微观数据[J/OL].海南大学学报(人文社会科学版):1-10[2023-11-03].https://doi.org/10.15886/j.cnki.hnus.202207.0331. [2] 程励,魏秀蓉,普片,2023.生态走廊带农户旅游获益与成本感知对其支持度的影响分析[J].农村经济(4):137-144. [3] 费孝通,1985.乡土中国[M].北京:生活·读书·新知三联书店. [4] 郭安禧,郭英之,李海军,等,2018.旅游者感知价值对重游意向影响的实证研究——旅游者满意和风险可能性的作用[J].旅游学刊(1):63-73. [5] 郭安禧,王松茂,李海军,等,2020.居民旅游影响感知对支持旅游开发影响机制研究——社区满意和社区认同的中介作用[J].旅游学刊(6):96-108. [6] 孔艺丹,黄子璇,陶卓民,等,2019.基于乡村性感知的游客环境责任行为影响机制研究——以南京市江宁区为例[J].南京师范大学学报(自然科学版)(1):124-131. [7] 李冬花,王咏,陆林,2023.共同富裕目标下综合乡村旅游开发的可持续生计效应——基于浙江省安吉县鲁家村的案例实证[J].自然资源学报(2):511-528. [8] 涂红伟,陈晔,江梓铭,2022.居民价值共创行为对游客公民行为的影响——游客感恩的中介效应与特质犬儒主义的调节效应[J/OL].南开管理评论:1-27[2023-11-04].http://kns.cnki.net/kcms/detail/12.1288.f.20221117.1453.002.html. [9] 谢礼珊,赵强生,马康,2019.旅游虚拟社区成员互动、感知利益和公民行为关系——基于价值共创的视角[J]. 旅游学刊(3):28-40. [10] 徐越倩,吴丹阳,陈宁,2021.地方满意度、地方依恋与社区公民行为关系研究——基于浙江省湖州市长兴县6个移民村的调查[J].地域研究与开发(3):175-180. [11] 杨燕,胡书玲,王坤,等,2023.少数民族旅游村寨的三生空间演变及驱动机制——以肇兴侗寨为例[J].经济地理(12):222-230. [12] 尹华光,费建杰,谢莎,2011.生态旅游视角下景区居民利益感知研究——以武陵源风景区为例[J].湖南大学学报(社会科学版)(5):81-87. [13] AP J,1992.Residents’ perceptions on tourism impacts[J].Annals of tourism research,19(4):665-690. [14] ASHFORTH B E,MAEL F,1989.Social identity theory and the organization[J].Academy of management review,14(1):20-39. [15] BALOGLU S,1998.An empirical investigation of attitude theory for tourist destinations:a comparison of visitors and nonvisitors[J].Journal of hospitality & tourism research,22(3):211-224. [16] BARTLETT M Y,DE STENO D,2006.Gratitude and prosocial behavior[J].Psychological science,17(4):319-325. [17] BATEMAN T S,ORGAN D W,1983.Job satisfaction and the good soldier:the relationship between affect and employee“citizenship”[J].Academy of management journal,26(4):587-595. [18] BLAU P M,1964.Exchange and power in social life[M].New York:John Wiley&Sons,Inc. [19] BOLEY B B,MCGEHEE N G,PERDUE R R,et al.,2014.Empowerment and resident attitudes toward tourism:strengthening the theoretical foundation through a Weberian lens[J].Annals of tourism research,49(11):33-50. [20] BONNIE K E,DE WAAL F B,2004.Primate social reciprocity and the origin of gratitude[M]//EMMONS R A,MCCULLOUGH M E.The psychology of gratitude.New York:Oxford University Press:213-229. [21] BUIL I,MARTÍNEZ E,MATUTE J,2016.From internal brand management to organizational citizenship behaviours:evidence from frontline employees in the hotel industry[J].Tourism management,57:256-271. [22] CHAN S H J,LAI H Y I,2017.Understanding the link between communication satisfaction,perceived justice and organizational citizenship behavior[J].Journal of business research,70:214-223. [23] CHEN C F,CHEN P C,2010.Resident attitudes toward heritage tourism development[J].Tourism geographies,12(4):525-545. [24] CHEN X Q,2017.A phenomenological explication of guanxi in rural tourism management[J].Tourism management,63:383-394. [25] CHEN Y,COTTAM E,LIN Z,2020.The effect of resident-tourist value co-creation on residents’ well-being[J].Journal of hospitality and tourism management,44(9):30-37. [26] CHOI H C,MURRAY I,2010.Resident attitudes toward sustainable community tourism[J].Journal of sustainable tourism,18(4):575-594. [27] CHOO H S,PARK S Y,PETRICK J F,2011.The influence of the resident’s identification with a tourism destination brand on their behavior[J].Journal of hospitality marketing & management,20(2):198-216. [28] CROPANZANO R,ANTHONY E L,DANIELS S R,et al.,2017.Social exchange theory:a critical review with theoretical remedies[J].Academy of management annals,11(1):479-516. [29] DESTENO D,BARTLETT M Y,BAUMANN J,et al.,2010.Gratitude as moral sentiment:emotion-guided cooperation in economic exchange[J].Emotion,10(2):289-293. [30] DUKERICH J M,GOLDEN B R,SHORTELL S M,2002.Beauty is in the eye of the beholder:the impact of organizational identification,identity,and image on the cooperative behaviors of physicians[J].Administrative science quarterly,47(3):507-533. [31] DYER P,GURSOY D,SHARMA B,et al.,2007.Structural modeling of resident perceptions of tourism and associated development on the Sunshine Coast,Australia[J].Tourism management,28(2):409-422. [32] EMMONS R A,MCCULLOUGH M E,2004.The psychology of gratitude[M].New York:Oxford University Press:145-166. [33] FAN L N,WU M Y,WALL G,et al.,2019.Community support for tourism in China’s Dong ethnic villages[J].Journal of tourism and cultural change,19(3):362-380. [34] FARH J L,ZHONG C B,ORGAN D W,2004.Organizational citizenship behavior in the People’s Republic of China[J].Organization science,15(2):241-253. [35] FEHR R,FULMER A,AWTREY E,et al.,2017.The grateful workplace:a multilevel model of gratitude in organizations[J].Academy of management review,42(2):361-381. [36] FERGUSON L,2011.Promoting gender equality and empowering women?Tourism and the third millennium development goal[J].Current issues in tourism,14(3):235-249. [37] FILEP S,MACNAUGHTON J,GLOVER T,2017.Tourism and gratitude:valuing acts of kindness[J].Annals of tourism research,66(9):26-36. [38] FORNELL C,LARCKER D F,1981.Evaluating structural equation models with unobservable variables and measurement error[J].Journal of marketing research,18(1):39-50. [39] FREDRICKSON B L,2004.Gratitude,like other positive emotions,broadens and builds[M]//EMMONS R A,MC CULLOUGH M E.The psychology of gratitude.New York:Oxford University Press:145-166. [40] GALVIN B M,LANGE D,ASHFORTH B E,2015.Narcissistic organizational identification:seeing oneself as central to the organization’s identity[J].Academy of management review,40(2):163-181. [41] GOULDNER A W,1960.The norm of reciprocity:a preliminary statement[J].American sociological review,25:161-178. [42] GRAHAM S,BARKER G P,1990.The down side of help:an attributional developmental analysis of helping behavior as low-ability cue[J].Journal of educational psychology,82:7-14. [43] GU H M,RYAN C,2008.Place attachment,identity and community impacts of tourism-the case of a Beijing Hutong[J].Tourism management,29:637-647. [44] GULLIFORD L,MORGAN B,KRISTJÁNSSON K,2013.Recent work on the concept of gratitude in philosophy and psychology[J].The journal of value inquiry,47(3):285-317. [45] HARRILL R,2004.Residents’ attitudes toward tourism development:a literature review with implications for tourism planning[J].Journal of planning literature,18(3):251-266. [46] HASLAM S A,2001.Psychology in organizations:the social identity approach[M].London:Sage. [47] HU J J,MA X L,XU X W,et al.,2022.Treat for affection?Customers’ differentiated responses to pro-customer deviance[J].Tourism management,93:104619. [48] HUANG M H,2015.The influence of relationship marketing investments on customer gratitude in retailing[J].Journal of business research,68(6):1318-1323. [49] HUO T T,YUAN F,HUO M M,et al.,2023.Residents’ participation in rural tourism and interpersonal trust in tourists:the mediating role of residents’ perceptions of tourism impacts[J].Journal of hospitality and tourism management,54:457-471. [50] JOHNSON R E,CHANG C H,YANG L Q,2010.Commitment and motivation at work:the relevance of employee identity and regulatory focus[J].Academy of management review,35(2):226-245. [51] KOCK N,HADAYA P,2018.Minimum sample size estimation in PLS-SEM:the inverse square root and gamma-exponential methods[J].Information systems journal,28(1):227-261. [52] LAWLER E J,2001.An affect theory of social exchange[J]American journal of sociology,107(2):321-352. [53] LAWLER E J,THYE S R,1999.Bringing emotions into social exchange theory[J].Annual review of sociology,25(1):217-244. [54] LAZARUS R S,LAZARUS B N,1994.Passion and reason:making sense of our emotions[M].New York:Oxford University Press. [55] LEE J,KYLE G,SCOTT D,2012.The mediating effect of place attachment on the relationship between festival satisfaction and loyalty to the festival hosting destination[J].Journal of travel research,51(6):754-767. [56] LEE T H,2013.Influence analysis of community resident support for sustainable tourism development[J].Tourism management,34:37-46. [57] LIN Z B,CHEN Y,FILIERI R,2017.Resident-tourist value co-creation:the role of residents' perceived tourism impacts and life satisfaction[J].Tourism management,61:436-442. [58] LINDBERG K,MUNANURA I E,KOOISTRA C,et al.,2021.Understanding effects of tourism on residents:a contingent subjective well-being approach[J].Journal of travel research,61(2):346-361. [59] MA L K,TUNNEY R J,FERGUSON E,2017.Does gratitude enhance prosociality?A meta-analytic review[J].Psychological bulletin,143(6):601-635. [60] MAEL F,ASHFORTIH B E,1992.Alumni and their alma mater:a partial test of the reformulated model of organizational identification[J].Journal of organizational behavior,13(2):103-123. [61] MARUYAMA N U,KEITH S J,WOOSNAM K M,2019.Incorporating emotion into social exchange:considering distinct resident groups’ attitudes towards ethnic neighborhood tourism in Osaka,Japan[J].Journal of sustainable tourism,27(8):1125-1141. [62] MAYER J D,SALOVEY P,GOMBERG-KAUFMAN S,et al.,1991.A broader conception of mood experience[J].Journal of personality and social psychology,60:100-111. [63] MCCULLOUGH M E,EMMONS R A,TSANG J A,2002.The grateful disposition:a conceptual and empirical topography[J].Journal of personality and social psychology,82(1):112-127. [64] MCCULLOUGH M E,KILPATRICK S D,EMMONS R A,et al.,2001.Is gratitude a moral affect?[J].Psychological bulletin,127(2):249-266. [65] MCCULLOUGH M E,TSANG J A,EMMONS R A,2004.Gratitude in intermediate affective terrain:links of grateful moods to individual differences and daily emotional experience[J].Journal of personality and social psychology,86(2):295-309. [66] MCGEHEE N G,ANDEREK K L,2004.Factors predicting rural residents’ support for tourism[J].Journal of travel research,43(2):131-140. [67] MITCHELL M S,CROPANZANO R S,QUISENBERRY D M,2012.Social exchange theory,exchange resources,and interpersonal relationships:a modest resolution of theoretical difficulties[M]//TORNBLOM K,KAZEMIIN A.Handbook of social resource theory.New York,NY:Springer:99-118. [68] NUNKOO R,GURSOY D,2012.Residents’ support for tourism:an identity perspective[J].Annals of tourism research,39(1):243-268. [69] NUNKOO R,RAMKISSOON H,2012.Power,trust,social exchange and community support[J].Annals of tourism research,39(2):997-1203. [70] NUNKOO R,SMITH S L J,RAMKISSOON H,2013.Residents’ attitudes to tourism:a longitudinal study of 140 articles from 1984 to 2010[J].Journal of sustainable tourism,21(1):5-25. [71] OAKLEY J,BUSH A J,MONCRIEF W C,et al.,2021.The role of customer entertainment in b2b sales strategy:comparative insights from professional buyers and salespeople[J].Industrial marketing management,92:190-201. [72] ORGAN D W,1988.Organizational citizenship behavior:the good soldier syndrome[M].Lexington,MA:Lexington Books. [73] ORTONY A,CLORE G L,COLLINS A,1988.The cognitive structure of emotions[M].New York:Cambridge University Press. [74] PALMATIER R W,JARVIS C B,BECHKOFF J R,et al.,2009.The role of customer gratitude in relationship marketing[J].Journal of marketing,73(5):1-18. [75] PAPPAS N,2014.Hosting mega events:Londoners’ support of the 2012 Olympics[J].Journal of hospitality & tourism management,21(1):10-17. [76] PILLAY N,PARK G,KIM Y K,et al.,2020.Thanks for your ideas:gratitude and team creativity[J].Organizational behavior and human decision processes,156:69-81. [77] PRATT M G,1998.To be or not to be?Central questions in organizational identification[J].Identity in organizations:building theory through conversations:171-207. [78] PUDDIFOOT J E,1996.Some initial considerations in the measurement of community identity[J].Journal of community psychology,24(4):327-336. [79] RASOOLIMANESH S M,RINGLE C M,JAAFAR M,et al.,2017.Urban vs.rural destinations:residents’ perceptions,community participation and support for tourism development[J].Tourism management,60:147-158. [80] RAYMOND C M,BROWN G,WEBER D,2010.The measurement of place attachment:personal,community,and environmental connections[J].Journal of environmental psychology,30(4):422-434. [81] RIBEIRO M A,PINTO P,SILVA J A,et al.,2017.Residents’ attitudes and the adoption of pro-tourism behaviours:the case of developing island countries[J].Tourism management,61:523-537. [82] ROBERTS R C,2004.The blessings of gratitude:a conceptual analysis[M]//EMMONS R A,MCCULLOUGH M E.The psychology of gratitude.New York:Oxford University Press:58-78. [83] SCOTT C R,2007.Communication and social identity theory:existing and potential connections in organizational identification research[J].Communication studies,58(2):123-138. [84] SOSCIA I,2007.Gratitude,delight,or guilt:the role of consumers’ emotions in predicting postconsumption behaviors[J].Psychology and marketing,24(10):871-894. [85] STRZELECKA M,BOLEY B B,STRZELECKA C,2017.Empowerment and resident support for tourism in rural central and eastern europe(CEE):the case of Pomerania,Poland[J].Journal of sustainable tourism,25(4):554-572. [86] SU L,WANG L,LAW R,et al.,2017.Influences of destination social responsibility on the relationship quality with residents and destination economic performance[J].Journal of travel & tourism marketing,34(4):488-502. [87] SU L J,HUANG S S,NEJATI M,2019.Perceived justice,community support,community identity and residents’ quality of life:testing an integrative model[J].Journal of hospitality and tourism management,41:1-11. [88] SU L J,SWANSON S R,2017.The effect of destination social responsibility on tourist environmentally responsible behavior:compared analysis of first-time and repeat tourists[J].Tourism management,60:308-321. [89] TAJFEL H,1978.Differentiation between social groups:studies in the social psychology of intergroup relations[M].London:Academic Press. [90] TAJFEL H,TURNER J,1979.An integrative theory of intergroup conflict[M]//AUSTIN W G,WORCHEL S.The social psychology of intergroup relations.Monterey:Brooks/Cole:33-47. [91] TU H,MA J,2022.Does positive contact between residents and tourists stimulate tourists’ environmentally responsible behavior?The role of gratitude and boundary conditions[J].Journal of travel research,66(8):1774-1790. [92] TURNER J C,1985.Social categorization and the self-concept:a social cognitive theory of group behavior[J].Advances in group processes,2:77-122. [93] UTKARSH,GUPTA R K,2022.Effects of confidence and social benefits on consumers’ extra-role and in-role behaviors:a social identity and social exchange perspective[J].Journal of retailing and consumer services,65:102879. [94] VAN KNIPPENBERG D,VAN DICK R,TAVARES S,2007.Social identity and social exchange:identification,support,and withdrawal from the job[J].Journal of applied social psychology,37(3):457-477. [95] VONG N T L,2015.The mediating role of place identity in the relationship between residents’ perceptions of heritage tourism and place attachment:the Macau youth experience[J].Journal of heritage tourism,10(4):1-13. [96] WANG J,WONG C K,2011.Understanding organizational citizenship behavior from a cultural perspective:an empirical study within the context of hotels in Mainland China[J].International journal of hospitality management,30(4):845-854. [97] WANG Y,SHEN H,YE S,et al.,2020.Being rational or emotional:an integrated model of residents’ support of ethnic tourism development[J].Journal of hospitality and tourism management,44:112-121. [98] WATERS L,2012.Predicting job satisfaction:contributions of individual gratitude and institutionalized gratitude[J].Psychology,3(12):1174-1176. [99] WEINER B,1986.An attributional theory of motivation and emotion[M].New York:Springer Verlag. [100] WEINER B,RUSSELL D,LERMAN D,1979.The cognition-emotion process in achievement-related contexts[J].Journal of personality and social psychology,37(7):1211-1220. [101] WOOD A M,FROH J J,GERAGHTY A W,2010.Gratitude and well-being:a review and theoretical integration[J].Clinical psychology review,30(7):890-905. [102] WOOD A M,MALTBY J,STEWART N,et al.,2008.A social-cognitive model of trait and state levels of gratitude[J].Emotion,8(2):281-290. [103] WOOSNAM K,ALESHINLOYE K,2013.Can tourists experience emotional solidarity with residents?Testing durkheim’s model from a new perspective[J].Journal of travel research,52(4):494-505. [104] WU M Y,WU X F,LI Q C,et al.,2022.Community citizenship behavior in rural tourism destinations:scale development and validation[J].Tourism management,89:104457. [105] YING T Y,JIANG J J,ZHOU Y G,2015.Networks,citizenship behaviours and destination effectiveness:a comparative study of two Chinese rural tourism destinations[J].Journal of sustainable tourism,23(8-9):1318-1340. [106] YING T Y,ZHOU Y G,2007.Community,governments and external capitals in China’s rural cultural tourism:a comparative study of two adjacent villages[J].Tourism management,28(1):96-107. [107] ZHANG H,XU H G,2019.Impact of destination psychological ownership on residents’ “place citizenship behavior”[J].Journal of destination marketing & management,14:100391. [108] ZHANG Y C,GUO Y X,NEWMAN N,2017.Identity judgements,work engagement and organizational citizenship behavior:the mediating effects based on group engagement model[J].Tourism management,61:190-197. |
[1] | 罗莹, 姚增福. 突发公共危机事件下乡村旅游者重游意愿的复杂性研究——基于模糊集定性比较分析方法[J]. 旅游科学, 2023, 37(6): 107-124. |
[2] | 孙雨芹, 张睿. 民族地区乡村旅游产业跨越动力及机制仿真研究——基于广西龙脊的实证证据[J]. 旅游科学, 2023, 37(6): 83-106. |
[3] | 吴茂英, 吴新芳, 李秋成. 乡村旅游地环境公民行为的量表开发与实证检验[J]. 旅游科学, 2023, 37(4): 58-75. |
[4] | 吕宛青, 汪熠杰. 基于心理账户的乡村旅游地居民环境责任行为演化与促进研究[J]. 旅游科学, 2023, 37(1): 23-42. |
[5] | 黄国琼, 王学基, 黄业坚. 旅游目的地的演变历程、热点与趋势研究——基于科学知识图谱分析[J]. 旅游科学, 2022, 36(6): 106-124. |
[6] | 余润哲, 黄震方, 何昭丽, 鲍佳琪, 郭叙淇, 莫雨亭. 动机视角下乡村旅游者主观幸福感的驱动机制研究——以皖南传统古村落为例[J]. 旅游科学, 2022, 36(6): 90-105. |
[7] | 郭志蒙, 白雨, 于文成. 双重监管下的乡村旅游厕所工程长效管护策略研究——考虑奖惩机制与两类维护模式[J]. 旅游科学, 2022, 36(3): 130-146. |
[8] | 张睿, 姬长旭. 民族地区乡村旅游职业农民知识转移演进过程研究——基于广西龙脊梯田景区的纵向单案例研究[J]. 旅游科学, 2022, 36(1): 50-72. |
[9] | 马晓龙, 陈泠静, 尹平, 李维维. 政府在推动乡村旅游投资中的作用:基于动态博弈的分析[J]. 旅游科学, 2020, 34(3): 19-31. |
[10] | 郁琦,李山. 上海市乡村旅游景点空间格局及可达性研究[J]. 旅游科学, 2018, 32(3): 51-62. |
[11] | 龚伟, 马木兰. 乡村旅游社区空间共同演化研究[J]. 旅游科学, 2014, 28(3): 49-62. |
[12] | 尹燕,周应恒. 不同乡村旅游地游客重游意愿的影响因素实证研究 ——基于江苏省苏南地区[J]. 旅游科学, 2013, 27(6): 83-95. |
[13] | 杜宗斌, 苏勤. 社区归属感对乡村旅游地居民社区参与的影响 ——以浙江安吉为例[J]. 旅游科学, 2013, 27(3): 61-71. |
[14] | 粟路军. 不同类型旅游地竞合关系研究——基于旅游者忠诚差异分析[J]. 旅游科学, 2011, 25(5): 41-56. |
[15] | 许峰,吕秋琳,秦晓楠,杨晓. 真实性视角下乡村旅游经济可持续开发研究[J]. 旅游科学, 2011, 25(1): 26-34. |
|
版权所有 © 2018 《旅游科学》编辑部 | 沪ICP备14045560号-1
地址:上海市桂林路100号上海师范大学12号楼211室 | 邮编:200234 | 电话:021-64322594 | Email:lykx@shnu.edu.cn
本系统由北京玛格泰克科技发有限公司设计开发