野生动物旅游研究：进展与展望

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 野生动物旅游作为探讨人与动物关系的重要实践,已成为国内外研究的热点之一,正确认识其发展历程和理论成果对促进人与自然和谐共生具有重要意义。通过对国内外野生动物旅游相关文献的系统分析,结果发现：（1）野生动物旅游研究主要经历了萌芽期（2000年以前）、探索期（2001年—2014年）和发展期（2015年以后）3个阶段;（2）研究内容主要聚焦影响与影响因素、冲突与管理、伦理转向三大方面,即“影响-冲突-管理-伦理”构成野生动物旅游研究的核心要素链;（3）野生动物旅游研究在理论完善、伦理转向、研究方法等方面存在不足,未来研究需不断丰富理论视角,构建野生动物旅游共同体,突破传统研究范式,创新研究方法。

关键词: 野生动物旅游, 影响分析, 冲突关系, 管理模式, 伦理转向

Abstract: Wildlife tourism, as an important practice to explore the relationship between humans and animals, has become one of the hot spots at home and abroad. A correct understanding of its development process and theoretical achievements is of great significance for promoting harmonious coexistence between human and nature. Through systematic analysis of literature on wildlife tourism both domestically and internationally, the results show that: (1) The research on wildlife tourism has mainly experienced three stages: the germination period (before 2000), the exploration period (2001—; 2014), and the development period (after 2015). (2) The research content mainly focuses on three aspects: influence and influencing factors, conflict and management, and ethical turn, that is, “influence-conflict-management-ethics” constitutes the core element chain of wildlife tourism research. (3) The research on wildlife tourism is deficient in theoretical perfection, ethical turn and research methods. In the future, it is still necessary to continuously enrich theoretical perspectives, build a wildlife tourism community, break through traditional research paradigms and innovate research methods.;

Key words: wildlife tourism, impact analysis, conflict relationship, management mode, ethical turn

中图分类号:

F590.7

严星雨, 徐菲菲, 钟雪晴. 野生动物旅游研究：进展与展望[J]. 旅游科学, 2024, 38(6): 41-57.

YAN Xingyu, XU Feifei, ZHONG Xueqing. Research on Wildlife Tourism：Progress and Prospect[J]. TOURISM SCIENCE, 2024, 38(6): 41-57.

参考文献

[1] 丛丽,吴必虎,2014.基于网络文本分析的野生动物旅游体验研究——以成都大熊猫繁育研究基地为例[J].北京大学学报(自然科学版)(6):1087-1094.
[2] 丛丽,吴必虎,李炯华,2012.国外野生动物旅游研究综述[J].旅游学刊(5):57-65.
[3] 崔庆明,2021.旅游能缓解保护地人与野生动物冲突吗?[J].中国生态旅游(5):663-675.
[4] 崔庆明,徐红罡,2012.野象的迷思:野象谷人-象冲突的社会建构分析[J].旅游学刊(5):49-56.
[5] 高科,2011.国外野生动物旅游研究综述[J].旅游科学(6):75-92.
[6] 高科,2012.野生动物旅游:概念、类型与研究框架[J].生态经济(6):137-140.
[7] 李进华,1998.野生灵长类资源的旅游开发与保护关系探讨[J].自然资源学报(4):84-87.
[8] 李奕,丛丽,2021.适应性管理视角的国外国家公园野生动物保护与游憩利用案例研究[J].中国生态旅游(5):691-704.
[9] 刘静,苗鸿,郑华,等,2009.卧龙自然保护区与当地社区关系模式探讨[J].生态学报(1):259-271.
[10] 马奔,温亚利,2022.人与野生动物冲突研究现状及经验启示[J].生态学报(8):3082-3092.
[11] 马建章,程鲲,2008.自然保护区生态旅游对野生动物的影响[J].生态学报(6):2818-2827.
[12] 孙九霞,2019.共同体视角下的旅游体验新论[J].旅游学刊(9):10-12.
[13] 泰勒,2010.尊重自然:一种环境伦理学理论[M].雷毅,李小重,高山,译.北京:首都师范大学出版社.
[14] 唐承财,向宝惠,钟林生,等,2011.西藏申扎县野生动物旅游社区参与模式研究[J].地理与地理信息科学(5):104-108.
[15] 温士贤,廖健豪,蔡浩辉,等,2021.旅游空间中的动物情感劳动与动物伦理困境[J].旅游科学(6):1-17.
[16] 王佳钰,蔡静,徐菲菲,2021.不同伦理取向野生动物旅游景区的游客具身性体验差异研究——基于网络文本评论与IPA模型分析[J].中国生态旅游(5):720-732.
[17] 尹铎,高权,朱竑,等,2017.广州鳄鱼公园野生动物旅游中的生命权力运作[J].地理学报(10):1872-1885.
[18] 张洪明,王玲.1997.试论动植物资源的旅游价值[J].华东森林经理(3):38-42.
[19] 张燕,2015.谁之权利?何以利用?——基于整体生态观的动物权利和动物利用[J].哲学研究(7):107-112.
[20] 张佑印,顾静,马耀峰,2013.旅游流研究的进展、评价与展望[J].旅游学刊(6):38-46.
[21] 钟义,2014.我国野生动物非政府保护组织面临的挑战与对策[J].国家林业局管理干部学院学报(3):13-16.
[22] ADAMS T S,CHASE M J,ROGERS T L,et al.,2016.Taking the elephant out of the room and into the corridor: can urban corridors work?[J].Oryx,51:1-7.
[23] ADELMAN L,FALK J,JAMES S,2000.Impact of national aquarium in Baltimore on visitors' conservation attitudes,behavior,and knowledge[J].Curator,43(1):33-60.
[24] APPS K,DIMMOCK K,HUVENEERS C,2018.Turning wildlife experience into conservation action:can white shark cage-dive tourism influence conservation behaviour?[J].Marine policy,88:108-115.
[25] ARDIANTIONO,JESSOP T S,PURWANDANA D,et al.,2018.Effects of human activities on Komodo dragons in Komodo National Park[J].Biodiversity and conservation,27:3329-3347.
[26] AYAA D D,WASWA F,2016.Role of indigenous knowledge systems in the conservation of the bio-physical environmental among the Teso community in Busia County-Kenya[J].Environmental science and technology,10(12):467-475.
[27] BALLANTYNE R,HUGHES K,LEE J,et al.,2021.Facilitating zoo/aquarium visitors' adoption of environmentally sustainable behavior:developing a values-based interpretation matrix[J].Tourism management,84:104243.
[28] BALLANTYNE R,PACKER J,FALK J,2011.Visitors' learning for environmental sustainability:testing short- and long-term impacts of wildlife tourism experiences using structural equation modelling[J].Tourism management,32:1243-1252.
[29] BELICIA T X Y,ISLAM M S,2018.Towards a decommodified wildlife tourism:why market environmentalism is not enough for conservation[J].Societies,8(3):59-73.
[30] BENTZ J,LOPES F,CALADO H,et al.,2016.Enhancing satisfaction and sustainable management:whale watching in the Azores[J].Tourism management,54:465-476.
[31] BUIJS A,JACOBS M,2021.Avoiding negativity bias:towards a positive psychology of human-wildlife relationships[J].Ambio,50(2):281-288.
[32] BULLER H,2015.Animal geographies Ⅱ:methods[J].Progress in human geography,39(3):374-384.
[33] BUTLER J R A,MIDDLEMAS S J,MCKELVEY S A,et al.,2008.The moray firth seal management plan:an adaptive framework for balancing the conservation of seals,salmon,fisheries and wildlife tourism in the UK[J].Aquatic conservation,18(6):1025-1038.
[34] CHRISTOU P A,NIKIFOROU E S,2021.Tourists' perceptions of non-human species in zoos:an animal rights perspective[J].International journal of tourism research,23(4):690-700.
[35] COHEN E,2019.Posthumanism and tourism[J].Tourism review of AIEST,74(3):416-427.
[36] CONVEY W,1995.Wild and zoo animal interactive management and habitat conservation[J].Biodiversity and conservation,4(2):573-594.
[37] CORIA J,CALFUCURA E,2012.Ecotourism and the development of indigenous communities:the good,the bad,and the ugly[J].Ecology economics,73:47-55.
[38] CUI Q M,REN Y J,XU H G,2021.The escalating effects on wildlife tourism on human-wildlife conflict[J].Animals,11(5):103390.
[39] CUI Q M,XU H G,2019.Situating animal ethics in Thai elephant tourism[J].Asia Pacific viewpoint,60(3):267-279.
[40] CURTIN S,2009.Wildlife tourism:the intangible,psychological benefits of human-wildlife encounters[J].Current issues in tourism,12(5-6):451-474.
[41] CZECH B,KRAUSMAN P R,DEVERS P K,2000.Economic associations among causes of species endangerment in the United States[J].BioScience,50:593-601.
[42] DAVIS D,1998.Whale shark tourism in Ningaloo Marine Park,Australia[J].Anthrozoos,11(1):5-11.
[43] DEARDEN M Y,2006.The potential impact of tourism development on habitat availability and productivity of Malaysian plovers Charadrius peronii[J].Journal of applied ecology,43(5):978-989.
[44] DLIMA C,WELTERS R,HAMANN M,et al.,2016.Using regional geographic scale substitution to value coastal wildlife tourism:implications for stakeholders,conservation and management[J].Ocean & coastal management,128:52-60.
[45] DUFFUS D A,DEARDEN P,1990.Non-consumptive wildlife-oriented recreation:a conceptual framework[J].Biological conservation,(3):213-231.
[46] FENNELL D A,2014.Exploring the boundaries of a new moral order for tourism' s global code of ethics:an opinion piece on the position of animals in the tourism industry[J].Journal of sustainable tourism,22(7):983-996.
[47] FENNELL D A,PANAH H Y,2020.Tourism and wildlife photography codes of ethics:developing a clearer picture[J].Annals of tourism research,85:103023.
[48] FENNELL D A,SHEPPARD V,2021.Tourism,animals and the scales of justice[J].Journal of sustainable tourism,29:2-3.
[49] FLOWER E K,BURNS G L,JONES D N,2021.How tourist preference and satisfaction can contribute to improved welfare standards at elephant tourism venues in Thailand[J].Animals,11(4):103390.
[50] HOBERG R,DYMAND L K,MULGREW K,et al.,2021.Humpback whale encounters:encouraging pro-environmental behaviours[J].Current issues in tourism,24(13):1918-1929.
[51] JACKSON Z I,2013.Animal:new directions in the theorization of race and posthumanism[J].Feminist studies,39(3):669-685.
[52] JACOBS M H,HARMS M,2014.Influence of interpretation on conservation intentions of whale tourists[J].Tourism management,42:123-131.
[53] JIMENEZ G,MELEMDEZ L,BLANCO G,et al.,2013.Dampened behavioral responses mediate birds' association with humans[J].Biological conservation,159:477-483.
[54] KING J M,HEINEN J T,2004.An assessment of the behaviors of overwintering manatees as influenced by interactions with tourists at two sites in central Florida[J].Biological conservation,117(3):227-234.
[55] KNIGHT R L,COLE D N,1995.Origin of Wildlife Responses to Recreationists[M].Washington:Island Press.
[56] LARM M,ELMHAGEN B,GRANQUIST S M,et al.,2018.The role of wildlife tourism in conservation of endangered species:implications of safari tourism for conservation of the Arctic fox in Sweden[J].Human dimensions of wildlife,23(3):257-272.
[57] LEE D J,KRUGER S,WHANG M,et al.,2014.Validating a customer well-being index related to natural wildlife tourism[J].Tourism management,45:171-180.
[58] LIU J G,DAILY G C,EHRLICH P R,et al.,2003.Effects of household dynamics on resource consumption and biodiversity[J].Nature,421(6922):530-533.
[59] LOSIF R,VLAD S E,STAESCU F,et al.,2019.Perception of visitors regarding the wildlife inhabiting an archaeological site[J].Human dimension of wildlife,24(4):301-313.
[60] LO Y,JANTA P,2021.Balancing commercialization and sustainability in community-based tourism practices—a qualitative study of factors affecting elephant habitat communities in northern Thailand[J].Frontiers in psychology,12:685426.
[61] LYON C,PARKINS J R,2013.Towards a social theory of resilience:social systems,cultural systems,and collective action in transitioning forest-based communities[J].Rural sociology,78:528-549.
[62] MACLELLAN L R,1999.An examination of wildlife tourism sustainable form of tourism development in North West Scotland[J].International journal of tourism research,(5):375-387.
[63] MARSCHALL S,GRANQUIST S M,BURNS G L,2017.Interpretation in wildlife tourism:assessing the effectiveness of signage on visitor behaviour at a seal watching site in Iceland[J].Journal of outdoor recreation and tourism,17:11-19.
[64] MARTIN J G A,REALE D,2008.Animal temperament and human disturbance:implications for the response of wildlife to tourism[J].Behavioural processes,77(1):66-72.
[65] MASSE F,2016.The political ecology of human-wildlife conflict producing wilderness,insecurity,and displacement in the Limpopo National Park[J].Conservation & society,14(2):100-111.
[66] MAZZOCCHI F,2008.Analyzing knowledge as part of a cultural framework:the case of traditional ecological knowledge[J].Environments,36:39-57.
[67] MCCLUNG M R,SEDDON P J,MASSARO M,et al.,2004.Nature-based tourism impacts on yellow-eyed penguins Megadyptes antipodes:does unregulated visitor access affect fledging weight and juvenile survival?[J].Biological conservation,119(2):279-285.
[68] MCCOOL S F,1996.Wildlife viewing,natural area protection,and community sustainability and resiliency[J].Natural areas journal,16(2):147-151.
[69] MOOREHOUSE T,DCRUZE N C,MACDONALD D W,2017.Unethical use of wildlife in tourism:what's the problem,who is responsible,and what can be done?[J].Journal of sustainable tourism,25(4):505-516.
[70] MORTON H,WINTER E,GROTE U,2016.Assessing natural resource management through integrated environmental and social-economic accounting:the case of a Namibian conservancy[J].Journal of environmental and development,25(4):396-425.
[71] MUTANGA C N,VENGESAYI S,CHIKUTA O,et al.,2017.Travel motivation and tourist satisfaction with wildlife tourism experiences in Gonarezhou and Matusadona National Parks,Zimbabwe[J].Journal of outdoor recreation tourism-research planning,20(1):1-18.
[72] MUTANGA C N,VENGESAYI S,MUBOKO N,et al.,2015.Towards harmonious conservation relationships:a framework for understanding protected area staff-local community relationships in developing countries[J].Journal for nature conservation,25:8-16.
[73] NEWSOME D,DOWLING R K,MOORE S A,2005.Wildlife Tourism[M].Clevedon:Multilingual Matters Ltd.
[74] NTULI H,JAGERS S C,LINELL A,et al.,2019.Factors influencing local communities' perceptions towards conservation of transboundary wildlife resources:the case of the Great Limpopo Trans-frontier Conservation Area[J].Biodiversity and conservation,28:2977-3003.
[75] ORAMS M B,2002.Feeding wildlife as a tourism attraction:a review of issues and impacts[J].Tourism management,23(3):281-293.
[76] PACKER J,BALLANTYNE R,HUGHES K,2014.Chinese and Australian tourists' attitudes to nature,animals and environmental issues:implications for the design of nature-based tourism experiences[J].Tourism management,44(10):101-107.
[77] PETER V H,LINUS K,ROMIE N,2022.The power of dissonance inconsistent relations between travelling ideas and local realities in community conservation in Namibia's Zambezi Region[J].Conservation and society,20(1):36-46.
[78] POTI M,LONG S L,RUSLI M U,et al.,2021.Changing trends and perceptions of sea turtle egg consumption in Redang Island,Malaysia[J].Ecology & society,26(4):14-27.
[79] RAMOS S C,2022.Understanding Yurok traditional ecological knowledge and wildlife management[J].Wildlife management,86(1):e22140.
[80] REYNOLDS P C,BRATHWAITE D,2001.Towards a conceptual framework for wildlife tourism[J].Tourism management,22:31-42.
[81] SABUHORO E,AYOREKIRE J,MUNANURA I E,2023.The quality of life and perceived human-wildlife conflicts among forest communities around the mountain gorilla's Virunga landscape in Africa[J].Sustainability,15(3):2248.
[82] SANDERSON S E,REDFORD K H,2003.Contested relationships between biodiversity conservation and poverty alleviation[J].Oryx,37:389-390.
[83] SARAH W,SANDIE S P,KATE L,2009.‘That means the fish are fat':sharing experiences of animals through indigenous-owned tourism[J].Current issues in tourism,12(5):505-527.
[84] SEKERCIOGLU C H,2002.Impacts of birdwatching on human and avian communities[J].Environmental conservation,29(3):282-289.
[85] SHACKELY M,1996.Wildlife Tourism[M].London:Thompson Business Press.
[86] SHANG Z,LUO J M,2023.Topic modelling for wildlife tourism online reviews:analysis of quality factors[J].Current issues in tourism,26(14):2317-2331.
[87] SHEPPARD V A,FENNELL D A,2019.Progress in tourism public sector policy:toward an ethic for non-human animals[J].Tourism management,73:134-142.
[88] STORMER N,WEAVER L C,STUART-HILL G,et al.,2019.Investigating the effects of community-based conservation on attitudes towards wildlife in Namibia[J].Biological conservation,233:193-200.
[89] SUKANAN D,ANTHONY B P,2019.Community attitudes towards bears,bear bile use,and bear conservation in Luang Prabang,Lao PDR[J].Journal of ethnobiology and ethnomedicine,15:1-15.
[90] TOMASSINI L,BERTELLA G,2024.The human gaze at animals and the missing animal gaze in tourism studies[J].Current issues in tourism,27:350-355.
[91] WARE M,FUENTES M M P B,2020.Leave no trace ordinances for coastal species management:influences on sea turtle nesting success[J].Endangered species research,41:197-207.
[92] WEAVER D B,JIN X,2016.Compassion as a neglected motivator for sustainable tourism[J].Journal of sustainable tourism,24(5):657-672.
[93] WIJK J V,DUIM R V D,LAMERS M,et al.,2015.The emergence of institutional innovations in tourism:the evolution of the African Wildlife Foundations' tourism conservation enterprises[J].Journal of sustainable tourism,23:104-125.
[94] WINTER C,2020.A review of research into animal ethics in tourism:launching the annals of tourism research curated collection on animal ethics in tourism[J].Annals of tourism research,84:102989.
[95] WOLF C,2003.Animal Rights:American Culture,the Discourse of Species,and Posthumanist Theory[M].Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
[96] YERBURY R M,BOYD W E,2018.Human-dolphin interactions:relationships,connections,and the reinforcement of an ongoing nature relationship[J].Anthrozoos,31(4):443-458.