照片呈现图式对旅游幸福感的影响研究——基于存在本真性的中介作用和社交媒体强度的调节作用

旅游科学 ›› 2024, Vol. 38 ›› Issue (6): 58-74.

照片呈现图式对旅游幸福感的影响研究——基于存在本真性的中介作用和社交媒体强度的调节作用

武慧慧^1,2, 何彪^1,2,*, 胡涛^1,2, 谢灯明^1,2

1.海南大学国际旅游与公共管理学院, 海南海口 571155;
2.海南省全域旅游研究基地, 海南海口 571155

收稿日期:2023-05-10 修回日期:2024-05-08 出版日期:2024-06-30 发布日期:2024-07-08
通讯作者: ^*何彪（1980—）,男,博士,海南大学国际旅游与公共管理学院教授,研究方向为生态旅游与绿色发展,E-mail：hebiao@hainanu.edu.cn。
作者简介:武慧慧（1994—）,女,海南大学国际旅游与公共管理学院博士生,研究方向旅游消费者行为,E-mail：wuhuihui@hainanu.edu.cn。胡涛（1968—）,男,博士,海南大学国际旅游与公共管理学院教授,博导,研究方向为旅游信息化。谢灯明（1995—）,男,博士,海南大学国际旅游与公共管理学院讲师,研究方向为旅游消费者行为。
基金资助:
国家社会科学基金项目“价值共创视角下旅游精准扶贫多主体参与机制研究”（19BGL139）; 海南省高等学校教育教学改革研究项目“海上丝绸之路沿线国家旅游教育合作平台构建与实施路径”（Hnjg2021ZD-4）; 海南省院士创新平台科研项目“数据感知、图解析技术及系统性风险处置研究”（YSPTZX202210）

The Effects of Photo-Sharing Types on Tourist Well-Being: The Mediation Role of Existential Authenticity and the Moderation Role of Social Media Intensity

WU Huihui^1,2, HE Biao^1,2,*, HU Tao^1,2, XIE Dengming^1,2

1. College of International Tourism and Public Administration, Hainan University, Haikou 571155, China;
2. Hainan Province Holistic Tourism Research Base, Haikou 571155, China

Received:2023-05-10 Revised:2024-05-08 Online:2024-06-30 Published:2024-07-08

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 分享旅游照片是一种普遍的游后行为,是游客自我景观化呈现的方式之一。但鲜有文献探究旅游照片分享对旅游幸福感的影响。文章以自我知觉理论为指导,旨在探讨游客在社交媒体分享的风景图式和自我景观化图式旅游照片如何通过存在本真性的中介作用影响旅游幸福感（享乐主义和实现主义幸福感）,以及社交媒体强度的调节作用。文章设计了3个实验,揭示了内省框架下不同游客照片呈现图式对旅游幸福感的影响机制。结果显示：风景图式会带来更好的享乐主义幸福感,自我景观化图式预示着更高的实现主义幸福感,存在本真性在以上关系中发挥中介作用,社交媒体强度调节上述两条中介路径。文章深化了自我知觉理论,丰富了旅游照片呈现和社交媒体支持对旅游体验影响的相关研究。

关键词: 自我景观化, 存在本真性, 旅游幸福感, 社交媒体强度, 自我知觉理论

Abstract: Sharing travel photos on social media is a common post-travel behavior, and it is one of the ways for tourists to self-spectacularization presentation. However, scant literature has explored the impact of travel photo-sharing on tourist well-being. Thus, based on the self-perception theory, this study aims to explore how tourists' sharing of scenery-type and self-spectacularization-type photos on social media affects tourist well-being (hedonic and eudemonic well-being) via existential authenticity, and examine the moderation role of social media intensity. This study designed three experiments to reveal the impacts of different online photo-sharing types on tourist well-being and its potential mechanism under the framework of introspection. The findings indicate that scenery-type photo-sharing can promote tourist hedonic well-being, while self-spectacularization-type photo-sharing can enhance tourist eudemonic well-being, existential authenticity mediates the relationship between scenery-type photo-sharing and tourist hedonic well-being, as well as the relationship between self-spectacularization-type photo-sharing and tourist eudemonic well-being, and social media intensity moderates the above two mediation paths. This study deepens the self-perception theory, and enriches the research on the influence of travel photo-sharing and social media support on travel experience.

Key words: self-spectacularization, existential authenticity, social media intensity, tourist well-being, the self-perception theory

中图分类号:

C913.3

武慧慧, 何彪, 胡涛, 谢灯明. 照片呈现图式对旅游幸福感的影响研究——基于存在本真性的中介作用和社交媒体强度的调节作用[J]. 旅游科学, 2024, 38(6): 58-74.

WU Huihui, HE Biao, HU Tao, XIE Dengming. The Effects of Photo-Sharing Types on Tourist Well-Being: The Mediation Role of Existential Authenticity and the Moderation Role of Social Media Intensity[J]. TOURISM SCIENCE, 2024, 38(6): 58-74.

参考文献

[1] 蔡礼彬,宋莉,2020.旅游者幸福感研究述评:基于扎根理论研究方法[J].旅游学刊(5):52-63.
[2] 陈岗,钱冲,麻丽芳,2020.旅游者摄影:旅游吸引物标志的识别与转化[J].旅游科学(4):89-101.
[3] 邓爱民,张馨方,2018.西方旅游本真性研究的知识图谱——基于CiteSpace Ⅲ的计量分析[J].旅游学刊(1):95-104.
[4] 范红霞,孙金波,2017.自拍:美颜盛世下的景观剥夺——基于社交媒体自我表达的社会性别考察[J].新闻爱好者(12):24-27.
[5] 黄剑锋,金红燕,陆林,等,2020.旅游本真性对旅游者地方依恋的影响研究——目的地形象和风险感知的作用[J].旅游学刊(12):38-51.
[6] 黄骏,徐皞亮,2021.“我晒故我在”:移动传播时代的青年游客凝视与自我建构[J].当代青年研究(5):56-62.
[7] 姜永志,白晓丽,张璐,等,2022.青少年线上积极自我呈现与幸福感的关系:线上积极反馈与自尊的作用[J].心理发展与教育(1):45-53.
[8] 廖圣清,李梦琦,2021.社交媒体中关系强度、自我呈现动机与用户转发意愿研究——以微信的新闻转发为例[J].现代传播(中国传媒大学学报)(6):149-156.
[9] 梅罗维茨,2002.消失的地域:电子媒介对社会行为的影响[M].肖志军,译.北京:清华大学出版社.
[10] 孙信茹,王东林,2019.身体表演与拍照的意义生产——社交媒体时代个人影像实践的田野考察[J].新闻大学(3):1-18;116.
[11] 王宁,2014.旅游伦理与本真性体验的文化心理差异[J].旅游学刊(11):5-6.
[12] 王汝辉,马志新,2020.客观本真与存在本真的互动:川藏线骑行旅游研究[J].四川师范大学学报(社会科学版)(6):64-73.
[13] 韦路,陈稳,2015.城市新移民社交媒体使用与主观幸福感研究[J].国际新闻界(1):114-130.
[14] 杨强,蒋玉石,周雪,等,2021.产品信息会在朋友圈坚持多久——身份认同与经济奖励对社交媒体用户分享意愿及分享时间的影响研究[J].南开管理评论(3):16-29.
[15] 杨恬,张放,2021.关系动机驱动自我呈现策略的跨文化逆反效应——基于在美中国旅居者社交媒体使用的实证研究[J].国际新闻界(6):73-97.
[16] 姚延波,贾广美,2021.社交媒体旅游分享对潜在旅游者冲动性旅游意愿的影响研究:基于临场感视角[J].南开管理评论(3):72-82.
[17] 袁佳钰,白凯,杜涛,等,2023.“携老型”家庭旅游中子代自我概念清晰性对其幸福感影响[J].旅游学刊(3):50-62.
[18] 周功梅,宋瑞,刘倩倩,2020.旅游摄影:研究述评与展望[J].旅游学刊(11):129-144.
[19] 朱竑,蔡晓梅,苏晓波,等,2020.“晒”与“赞”:微信时代旅游体验的互动建构[J].旅游学刊(10):96-108.
[20] BARRY C T,REITER S R,ANDERSON A C,et al.,2019.“Let me take another selfie”:further examination of the relation between narcissism,self-perception,and Instagram posts[J].Psychology of popular media culture,8(1):22-33.
[21] BEM D J,1967.Self-perception:an alternative interpretation of cognitive dissonance phenomena[J].Psychological review,74(3):183.
[22] BEM D J,1972.Self-perception theory[J].Advances in experimental social psychology,6:1-62.
[23] BINKHORST E,DEN DEKKER T,2009 Agenda for co-creation tourism experience research[J].Journal of hospitality marketing & management,18(2-3):311-327.
[24] BIRAGLIA A,GERRATH M H E E,USREY B,2018.Examining how companies' support of tourist attractions affects visiting intentions:the mediating role of perceived authenticity[J].Journal of travel research,57(6):811-823.
[25] CHEN Y,LIU Y,WU L,et al.,2022.How does mobile social media sharing benefit travel experiences?[J].Journal of travel research,62(4):841-858.
[26] CHU S C,WINDELS K,KAMAL S,2016.The influence of self-construal and materialism on social media intensity:a study of China and the United States[J].International journal of advertising,35(3):569-588.
[27] CONTI E,LEXHAGEN M,2020.Instagramming nature-based tourism experiences:a netnographic study of online photography and value creation[J].Tourism management perspectives,34:100650.
[28] DEBORD G,1994.The commodity as spectacle[J].Media and cultural studies:keyworks,117-21.
[29] DENG N,LIU J,2021.Where did you take those photos? Tourists' preference clustering based on facial and background recognition[J].Journal of destination marketing & management,21:100632.
[30] DINHOPL A,GRETZEL U,2016.Selfie-taking as touristic looking[J].Annals of tourism research,57:126-139.
[31] ELLISON N B,STEINFIELD C,LAMPE C,2007.The benefits of Facebook “friends”:social capital and college students' use of online social network sites[J].Journal of computer‐mediated communication,12(4):1143-1168.
[32] GILLET S,SCHMITZ P,MITAS O,2016.The snap-happy tourist:the effects of photographing behavior on tourists' happiness[J].Journal of hospitality & tourism research,40(1):37-57.
[33] HAYBRON,D M,2000.Two philosophical problems in the study of happiness[J].Journal of happiness studies,1:207-225.
[34] HAYES A F,SCHARKOW M,2013.The relative trustworthiness of inferential tests of the indirect effect in statistical mediation analysis:does method really matter?[J].Psychological science,24(10):1918-1927.
[35] HÖCKERT E,LÜTHJE M,ILOLA H,et al.,2018.Gazes and faces in tourist photography[J].Annals of tourism research,73:131-140.
[36] HODGETTS D,CHAMBERLAIN K,RADLEY A,2007.Considering photographs never taken during photo-production projects[J].Qualitative research in psychology,4(4):263-280.
[37] HSU F C,AGYEIWAAH E,LYNN I,et al.,2021.Examining food festival attendees' existential authenticity and experiential value on affective factors and loyalty:an application of stimulus-organism-response paradigm[J].Journal of hospitality and tourism management,48:264-274.
[38] HUTA V,RYAN R M,2010.Pursuing pleasure or virtue:the differential and overlapping well-being benefits of hedonic and eudaimonic motives[J].Journal of happiness studies,11:735-762.
[39] KOLAR T,ZABKAR V,2010.A consumer-based model of authenticity:an oxymoron or the foundation of cultural heritage marketing?[J].Tourism management,31(5):652-664.
[40] LEE C,RICHARDSON S,GOH E,et al.,2023.From the tourist gaze to a shared gaze:exploring motivations for online photo-sharing in present-day tourism experience[J].Tourism management perspectives,46:101099.
[41] LENGIEZA M L,HUNT C A,SWIM J K,2019.Measuring eudaimonic travel experiences[J].Annals of tourism research,74(1):195-197.
[42] LI F,2020.Understanding Chinese tourists' motivations of sharing travel photos in WeChat[J].Tourism management perspectives,33,100584.
[43] LO I S,MCKERCHER B,LO A,et al.,2011.Tourism and online photography[J].Tourism management,32(4):725-731.
[44] MARINO C,LISTA C,SOLARI D,et al.,2022.Predicting comments on Facebook photos:who posts might matter more than what type of photo is posted[J].Addictive behaviors reports,15:100417.
[45] MENG B,HAN H,2019.Determinants of working holiday makers' destination loyalty:uncovering the role of perceived authenticity[J].Tourism management perspectives,32:100565.
[46] MUNAR A M,JACOBSEN J K S,2014.Motivations for sharing tourism experiences through social media[J].Tourism management,43:46-54.
[47] MKONO M,2013.African and western tourists:object authenticity quest?[J].Annals of tourism research,41,195-214.
[48] MOORE K,BUCHMANN A,MÅNSSON M,et al.,2021.Authenticity in tourism theory and experience:practically indispensable and theoretically mischievous?[J].Annals of tourism research,89:103208.
[49] MOSTAFANEZHAD M,NORUM R,2018.Tourism in the post-selfie era[J].Annals of tourism research,70:131-132.
[50] NIKJOO A,BAKHSHI H,2019.The presence of tourists and residents in shared travel photos[J].Tourism management,70:89-98.
[51] NIU G,SUN L,LIU Q,et al.,2020.Selfie-posting and young adult women's restrained eating:the role of commentary on appearance and self-objectification[J].Sex roles,82:232-240.
[52] OLIVEIRA T,ARAUJO B,TAM C,2020.Why do people share their travel experiences on social media?[J].Tourism management,78:104041.
[53] PAN S,LEE J,TSAI H,2014.Travel photos:motivations,image dimensions,and affective qualities of places[J].Tourism management,40:59-69.
[54] PREBENSEN N K,LARSEN S,ABELAEN B,2003.I'm not a typical tourist:German tourists' self-perception,activities,and motivations[J].Journal of travel research,41(4):416-420.
[55] RAHMANI K,GNOTH J,MATHER D,2018.Hedonic and eudaimonic well-being:a psycholinguistic view[J].Tourism management,69:155-166.
[56] REINECKE L,TREPTE S,2014.Authenticity and well-being on social network sites:a two-wave longitudinal study on the effects of online authenticity and the positivity bias in SNS communication[J].Computers in human behavior,30:95-102.
[57] SIRGY M,2019.Promoting quality-of-life and well-being research in hospitality and tourism[J].Journal of travel & tourism marketing,36(1):1-13.
[58] SMITH M K,DIEKMANN A,2017.Tourism and wellbeing[J].Annals of tourism research,66:1-13.
[59] STEPCHENKOVA S,ZHAN F,2013.Visual destination images of Peru:comparative content analysis of DMO and user-generated photography[J].Tourism management,36:590-601.
[60] SU L,SWANSON S R,CHEN X,2016.The effects of perceived service quality on repurchase intentions and subjective well-being of Chinese tourists:the mediating role of relationship quality[J].Tourism management,52:82-95.
[61] TAYLOR D G,2020.Putting the "self" in selfies:how narcissism,envy and self-promotion motivate sharing of travel photos through social media.Journal of travel & tourism marketing,37(1):64-77.
[62] VIDON E S,RICKLY J M,KNUDSEN D C,2018.Wilderness state of mind:expanding authenticity[J].Annals of tourism research,73:62-70.
[63] WANG N,1999.Rethinking authenticity in tourism experience[J].Annals of tourism research,26(2):349-370.
[64] WANG S W,HUANG C Y,SUN C T,2014.Modeling self-perception agents in an opinion dynamics propagation society[J].Simulation,90(3):238-248.
[65] WANG S,XU H,2015.Influence of place-based senses of distinctiveness,continuity,self-esteem and self-efficacy on residents' attitudes toward tourism[J].Tourism management,47:241-250.
[66] WOOSNAM K M,DRAOER J,JIANG J K,et al.,2018.Applying self-perception theory to explain residents' attitudes about tourism development through travel histories[J].Tourism management,64:357-368.
[67] YACHIN J M,2018.The ‘customer journey':learning from customers in tourism experience encounters[J].Tourism management perspectives,28:201-210.
[68] YI X,FU X,LIN V S,et al.,2022.Integrating authenticity,well-being,and memorability in heritage tourism:a two-site investigation[J].Journal of travel research,61(2):378-393.
[69] YI X,FU X,YU L,et al.,2018.Authenticity and loyalty at heritage sites:the moderation effect of postmodern authenticity[J].Tourism management,67:411-424.