旅游对贸易的溢出效应及门槛特征——来自中国-东盟的实证检验

旅游科学 ›› 2025, Vol. 39 ›› Issue (1): 160-174.

• • 上一篇

旅游对贸易的溢出效应及门槛特征——来自中国-东盟的实证检验

陈乔, 毛焱^*

湖北经济学院旅游与酒店管理学院,湖北武汉 430205

收稿日期:2023-06-13 修回日期:2025-01-09 出版日期:2025-01-30 发布日期:2025-04-09
通讯作者: 毛焱^*（1975—）,女,博士,湖北经济学院旅游与酒店管理学院教授,研究方向为旅游企业管理,E-mail：yanmao@hbue.edu.cn。
作者简介:陈乔（1984—）,男,博士,湖北经济学院旅游与酒店管理学院副教授,研究方向为旅游经济,E-mail：chenqiao@hbue.edu.cn。
基金资助:
教育部人文社会科学研究青年基金项目"数字经济提升长三角城市群旅游流韧性的机制及效应研究"（24YJC790013）

The Spillover Effects of Tourism on Trade and Characteristics of Thresholds —Empirical Test from China and ASEAN

CHEN Qiao, MAO Yan^*

School of Tourism and Hospitality Management, Hubei University of Economics, Wuhan 430205, China

Received:2023-06-13 Revised:2025-01-09 Online:2025-01-30 Published:2025-04-09

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 旅游发展促进了文化传播,增进了彼此友谊,为贸易增长奠定了坚实的民心基础,然而旅游对贸易影响效应的探讨尚不充分。文章以1995—2019年中国-东盟旅游和贸易数据为基础,实证考察旅游对贸易的溢出效应及门槛特征。结果表明：（1）旅游对贸易具有显著的溢出效应,且"出境对进口"溢出效应大于"入境对出口"。（2）在中国-东盟自贸区筹备、启动和建成各阶段内,入境对出口溢出效应逐步减弱,然而出境对进口的溢出逐年增强。（3）旅游对贸易的溢出效应,存在基于旅游专业化的双重门槛。随着旅游专业化水平的不断提高,出、入境旅游分别对进、出口贸易的溢出效应呈现"先增后减"态势,而且出境对进口的门槛明显大于入境对出口。研究结论可为中国-东盟国家旅游与贸易合作提供决策参考和重要启示。

关键词: 出入境旅游, 进出口贸易, 溢出效应, 门槛特征, 作用机理

Abstract: Tourism development has promoted cultural exchange, enhanced friendship, and laid a solid foundation for trade growth. However, the exploration of the spillover effects and threshold characteristics of tourism on trade is still insufficient. Based on the China-ASEAN tourism and trade data from 1995 to 2019, this study empirically examined the spillover effects and threshold characteristics of tourism on trade. The results show that: (1) Tourism has a significant spillover effect on trade, and the spillover effect of "outbound on imports" is greater than that of "inbound on exports". (2) During the preparation, initiation, and establishment stages of the China-ASEAN Free Trade Area, the spillover effect of "inbound on exports" gradually weakened, while the spillover effect of "outbound on imports" increased year by year. (3) The spillover effect of tourist numbers on trade scale has a dual threshold based on tourism specialization. With the continuous improvement of tourism specialization, the spillover effects of inbound and outbound tourism on exports and imports respectively show a "first increase and then decrease" trend, and the threshold for outbound on imports is significantly higher than that for inbound on exports. This study provides valuable decision-making references and important insights for tourism and trade cooperation between China and ASEAN countries.

Key words: inbound and outbound tourism, import and export trade, spillover effects, threshold characteristics, action mechanism

中图分类号:

F592

陈乔, 毛焱. 旅游对贸易的溢出效应及门槛特征——来自中国-东盟的实证检验[J]. 旅游科学, 2025, 39(1): 160-174.

CHEN Qiao, MAO Yan. The Spillover Effects of Tourism on Trade and Characteristics of Thresholds —Empirical Test from China and ASEAN[J]. TOURISM SCIENCE, 2025, 39(1): 160-174.

参考文献

[1] 包富华,2017.FDI与入境商务旅游的互动关系:过程、格局与机制[D].西安:陕西师范大学.
[2] 陈乔,程成,宋建林,2017.中国-东盟旅游与贸易互动关系研究[J].广西社会科学(10):72-77.
[3] 陈晓静,2015.欧盟旅游业发展与经济增长关系研究[D].上海:华东师范大学.
[4] 程成,周泽奇,鲁建琪,2020.中国-东盟旅游流空间分异与优化策略[J].经济地理(9):204-212.
[5] 国家统计局国际统计信息中心,广西壮族自治区统计局,国家统计局广西调查总队,2021.中国-东盟统计年鉴2020[M].北京:中国统计出版社.
[6] 郭小洁,司显柱,2022.文化传播调节作用下文化距离对来华旅游的非线性影响[J].财贸研究(2):20-30.
[7] 何蔓莉,孙根紧,2019.中国国际货物贸易的入境旅游效应研究[J].价格月刊(11):86-94.
[8] 黄爱莲,朱俊蓉,罗平雨,2021.边境旅游与边境贸易耦合协调研究——以东兴边境为例[J].世界地理研究(3):657-666.
[9] 李芬英,陈瑛,刘二虎,2017.中国-澳大利亚旅游与贸易互动关系研究[J].资源开发与市场(6):721-726.
[10] 李光勤,蒲康云,2023.留学中国与入境旅游——基于信任水平与贸易规模的视角[J].旅游科学(3):106-125.
[11] 刘玉萍,郭郡郡,2011.入境旅游与对外贸易的关系——基于中国2001—2008年月度数据的实证分析[J].经济地理(4):696-700.
[12] 石张宇,2019.我国国际货物贸易与出入境旅游的互动关系及其溢出效应[J].统计与决策(6):124-127.
[13] 苏建军,徐璋勇,赵多平,2013.国际货物贸易与入境旅游的关系及其溢出效应[J].旅游学刊(5):43-52.
[14] 孙根年,周露,2012.日韩东盟8国入境我国旅游与进出口贸易关系的研究[J].人文地理(6):87-94.
[15] 唐睿,2020.贸易便利化不平衡与国际旅游产业协调发展——来源于金砖国家的经验证据[J].经济问题探索(9):121-131.
[16] 韦永贵,张艺川,2021.跨国文化传播对中国出口贸易的影响研究——基于友好城市的研究视角[J].南方经济(11):97-121.
[17] 夏杰长,季雪飞,孙盼盼,2022.RCEP区域贸易与旅游耦合效应的网络结构特征及演化规律[J].社会科学家(12):71-79.
[18] 肖宇,季雪飞,李博文,2022.RCEP区域贸易与旅游耦合效应溢出规律及驱动因素研究[J].价格理论与实践(11):176-180.
[19] 叶莉,夏惟怡,钟璇,2022.广西旅游经济-生态环境耦合协调发展研究[J].改革与战略(4):132-140.
[20] 曾燕萍,2019.信任及其对经济发展的影响:一个研究综述[J].国外社会科学(2):75-81.
[21] 章秀琴,2019.旅游传播语境下入境旅游对我国出口贸易的影响[J].四川旅游学院学报(1):70-74.
[22] 赵多平,孙根年,2017.基于文化关联的旅游与贸易互动路径及机理研究——以宁夏与阿拉伯国家为例[J].地理科学(12):1815-1822.
[23] 郑鹏,刘壮,王洁洁,等,2023."因商而游"亦或"寻文而至"?——"一带一路"倡议与中国入境旅游业[J].中国人口·资源与环境(3):181-193.
[24] 朱海艳,2021.城市规模门槛下的旅游发展与经济增长关系[J].旅游科学(2):17-29.
[25] ALOLA U V,COP S,ALOLA A A,2019.The spillover effects of tourism receipts,political risk,real exchange rate,and trade indicators in Turkey[J].International journal of tourism research,21(6):813-823.
[26] ALONSO W,2021.A reformulation of classical location theory and its relation to rent theory[J].Papers of the regional science association,19(1):22-44.
[27] BARKAS P,HONECK D,RUBIO E,2020.International trade in travel and tourism services:economic impact and policy responses during the COVID-19 crisis[R].WTO Staff Working Paper.
[28] CALISKAN U,SALTIK I A,CEYLAN R,2019.Panel cointegration analysis of relationship between international trade and tourism:case of Turkey and silk road countries[J].Tourism management perspectives,31:361-369.
[29] GREIF A,1994.Cultural beliefs and the organization of society:a historical and theoretical reflection on collectivist and individualist societies[J].Journal of political economy,5(102):912-950.
[30] GUISO L,ZINGALES S L,2006.Does culture affect economic outcomes?[J].Journal of economic perspectives,20(2):23-48.
[31] HANSEN B E,1999.Threshold effects in non-dynamic panels:estimation,testing,and inference[J].Journal of econometrics,93(2):345-368.
[32] HATEFTABAR F,2021.The impact of psychological distance on tourists' length of stay:survival analysis[J].Journal of hospitality and tourism management,46:1-11.
[33] HOAN P T,LE H N T,DIEU M D T,2023.Examining the relationship between tourism,trade,and income:evidence from Vietnam[J].International journal of business ecosystem & strategy,5(3):107-114.
[34] KATIRCIOGLU S,ALTUN O,2018.The moderating role of oil price changes in the effects of service trade and tourism on growth:the case of Turkey[J].Environmental science and pollution research,25:35266-35275.
[35] KEINTZ R M,1971.A study of the demand for international travel to and from the United States[J].American economist,15(1):551-559.
[36] KONGBUAMAI N,ZAFAR M W,ZAIDI S A H,2020.Determinants of the ecological footprint in Thailand:the influences of tourism,trade openness,and population density[J].Environmental science and pollution research,27:40171-40186.
[37] KULENDRAN N,WILSON K,2000.Is there a relationship between international trade and international travel?[J].Applied economics,32(8):1001-1009.
[38] LANZA A,TEMPLE P,URGA G,2003.The implication of tourism specialization in the long-run:an econometric analysis for 13 OBCD economies[J].Tourism management,24(3):315-321.
[39] LUO Y,ZHANG L,ZHANG Y,2022.Inbound tourism and bilateral trade,evidence from China[J].Current issues in tourism,25(16):2595-2614.
[40] POOLE J,2010.Business travel as an input to international trade[Z].Santa Cruz,CA:UC Santa Cruz.
[41] SANTANA-GALLEGO M,LEDESMA-RODRÍGUEZ F J,PÉREZ-RODRÍGUEZ J V,2016.International trade and tourism flows:an extension of the gravity model[J].Economic modelling,52:1026-1033.
[42] SEATON,PHILIP,2018.War,popular culture,and contents tourism in East Asia[J].Journal of war & culture studies,12(1):1-7.
[43] SEZER S,2020.Relationship between foreign trade and tourism:an empirical study on mediterranean countries[J].Eurasian economic perspectives,13(1):437-454.
[44] SURESH K G,TIWARI A K,2018.Does international tourism affect international trade and economic growth?The Indian experience[J].Empirical economics,54:945-957.
[45] TANG R,2021.Trade facilitation promoted the inbound tourism efficiency in Japan[J/OL].Tourism management perspectives,38:100805.https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tmp.2021.100805.
[46] WANG C M,PAN S L,MORRISON A M,2022.The dynamic linkages among outbound tourism,economic growth,and international trade:empirical evidence from China[J].SN business & economics,2(11):169-187.
[47] XU L,WANG S,LI J,2019.Modelling international tourism flows to China:a panel data analysis with the gravity model[J].Tourism economics,25(7):1047-1069.
[48] ZAFAR S Z,ZHILIN Q,MABROUK F,et al.,2023.Empirical linkages between ICT,tourism,and trade towards sustainable environment:evidence from BRICS countries[J].Economic research-Ekonomska istraživanja,36(2):1-23.

旅游对贸易的溢出效应及门槛特征——来自中国-东盟的实证检验

The Spillover Effects of Tourism on Trade and Characteristics of Thresholds —Empirical Test from China and ASEAN

PDF (PC)

赞

可视化

摘要/Abstract

引用本文

使用本文

参考文献

相关文章 6

Metrics

本文评价

推荐阅读 0

[1]	雷振仙, 王坤. 城市旅游景区游客流动时空动态与溢出效应——以贵阳市为例[J]. 旅游科学, 2024, 38(7): 79-96.
[2]	唐睿, 栗明钰. 长三角数字经济驱动旅游业高质量发展的效应研究[J]. 旅游科学, 2024, 38(3): 24-43.
[3]	赵书虹, 张鸿, 孔营营, 杨兰, 杨越琴, 杨雨婷. 旅游如何促进积极老龄化?——基于扎根理论的研究[J]. 旅游科学, 2023, 37(3): 20-31.
[4]	刘佳, 刘贤明, 李煜轩. 文明城市评选与旅游经济发展：“锦上添花”还是“雪中送炭”?[J]. 旅游科学, 2022, 36(6): 45-70.
[5]	王佳莹, 张辉. 旅游发展、空间溢出与区域经济不平衡[J]. 旅游科学, 2021, 35(2): 73-94.
[6]	许峰,吕秋琳,秦晓楠,杨晓. 真实性视角下乡村旅游经济可持续开发研究[J]. 旅游科学, 2011, 25(1): 26-34.