合作何以共赢?酒店合作策略助推顾客绿色消费意愿以小拨大效应研究

旅游科学 ›› 2022, Vol. 36 ›› Issue (5): 1-20.

• • 下一篇

合作何以共赢?酒店合作策略助推顾客绿色消费意愿以小拨大效应研究

郭养红^1,*, 胥兴安²

1.兰州理工大学经济管理学院,甘肃兰州 730050;
2.海南大学旅游学院,海南海口 570228

收稿日期:2021-06-23 修回日期:2022-04-20 出版日期:2022-10-30 发布日期:2023-01-10
通讯作者: ^*
作者简介:郭养红^*（1984—）,男,博士,兰州理工大学经济管理学院副教授,研究方向为旅游消费心理与行为,E-mail：guoyanghong2008@163.com。胥兴安（1983—）,男,博士,海南大学旅游学院教授,博导,研究方向为旅游心理与行为。
基金资助:
国家自然科学基金项目“群体服务失败下感知集体情绪过当性对顾客参与服务补救影响”（71962006）; 甘肃省高等学校创新基金项目“酒店默认选项设置助推顾客绿色消费意愿实验研究——以甘肃为例”（2021A-018）; 兰州理工大学高等教育研究项目“新时代大学生创业意愿多层面驱动因素及其对创业行为的影响研究”（GJ2021B-32）

How to Win-Win Cooperation?The Small Predicts Large Effect of Hotel's Cooperation Strategy in Nudging Customers' Green Consumption Intentions

GUO Yanghong^1,*, XU Xing'an²

1. School of Economics and Management, Lanzhou University of Technology, Lanzhou 730050, China;
2. School of Tourism, Hainan University, Haikou 570228, China

Received:2021-06-23 Revised:2022-04-20 Online:2022-10-30 Published:2023-01-10

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 文章基于社会交换理论和归因理论,运用情景模拟实验法,探究酒店合作策略助推顾客绿色消费意愿的作用机制及边界条件。研究发现：酒店合作策略能有效助推顾客绿色消费意愿,且互惠型合作策略比诱因型合作策略更能有效助推顾客绿色消费意愿;亏欠感在酒店合作策略影响顾客绿色消费意愿中起中介作用,且互惠型合作策略比诱因型合作策略更能增进顾客亏欠感;亏欠感在酒店合作策略与顾客绿色消费意愿间的中介效应受顾客动机归因的调节,最终对顾客绿色消费意愿形成有调节的中介作用。文章拓展了合作策略激励助推方法在酒店绿色消费领域的理论及实证研究,推进了顾客动机归因和酒店绿色消费相关研究,并为酒店如何有效激发顾客绿色消费意愿提供了决策指导。

关键词: 酒店合作策略, 助推, 以小拨大效应, 亏欠感, 动机归因

Abstract: Based on Social Exchange Theory and Attribution Theory,this paper explores the small predicts large effect of hotel's cooperation strategy in nudging customers' green consumption intentions,it also investigate the mediating role of perceived indebtedness,and the moderating role of customers' motivation attribution in the hotel's cooperation strategy effect on customers' green consumption intentions.Three experiments were conducted in this paper.The first experiment results showed that hotel's cooperation strategy can effectively nudge customers' green consumption intentions.In experiment 2,the results showed that customers' green consumption intentions under the reciprocal-based cooperation strategy were significantly higher than those under the incentive-based cooperation strategy,and perceived indebtedness played a mediating role in the relationship between hotel's cooperation strategy and customers' green consumption intentions.The third experiment examined the moderating role of customers' motivation attribution,the results showed that customers' motivation attribution played a moderating role in the relationship between hotel's cooperation strategy and customer's green consumption intentions.Further,customers' motivation attribution moderates the mediating role of perceived indebtedness in the relationship between hotel's cooperation strategy and customer's green consumption intentions.In summary,the results of this paper contribute to the cooperation strategy,motivation attribution and green hotel consumption literature by demonstrating that the hotel's cooperation strategy can effectively nudge customers' green consumption intentions,and it also provide an effective strategy enabling hotels to stimulate customers' green consumption intentions.

Key words: hotel cooperation strategy, nudge, green consumption, perceived indebtedness, motivation attribution

中图分类号:

F 719.2

郭养红, 胥兴安. 合作何以共赢?酒店合作策略助推顾客绿色消费意愿以小拨大效应研究[J]. 旅游科学, 2022, 36(5): 1-20.

GUO Yanghong, XU Xing'an. How to Win-Win Cooperation?The Small Predicts Large Effect of Hotel's Cooperation Strategy in Nudging Customers' Green Consumption Intentions[J]. TOURISM SCIENCE, 2022, 36(5): 1-20.

参考文献

[1] 邓新明,张婷,许阳,等,2016.企业社会责任对消费者购买意向的影响研究[J].管理学报(7):1019-1027.
[2] 杜伟强,曹花蕊,2013.基于自身短期和社会长远利益两难选择的绿色消费机制[J].心理科学进展(5):775-784.
[3] 樊亚凤,蒋晶,崔稳权,2019.网络公益平台默认选项设置对个人捐赠意愿的影响及作用机制[J].心理学报(4):1-13.
[4] 傅鑫媛,辛自强,楼紫茜,等,2019.基于助推的环保行为干预策略[J].心理科学进展(11):1939-1950.
[5] 耿晓伟,张峰,王艳净,等,2018.健康目标启动降低高热量食物消费[J].心理学报(8):840-847.
[6] 何贵兵,李纾,梁竹苑,2018.以小拨大:行为决策助推社会发展[J].心理学报(8):803-813.
[7] 黄元娜,宋星元,邵洋,等,2019.以小拨大:默认选项和反应模式效应助推中国器官捐献登记[J].心理学报(8):868-879.
[8] 李佳洁,于彤彤,2020.基于助推的健康饮食行为干预策略[J].心理科学进展(12):2052-2063.
[9] 刘军,朱征,王琦琦,等,2019.工作场所感恩研究述评与展望[J].外国经济与管理(9):61-74.
[10] 粟路军,唐彬礼,2020.“先扬后抑,还是先抑后扬”?旅游地社会责任的信息框架效应研究[J].旅游科学(6):86-105.
[11] 王纯阳,李文俊,冯芷菁,2020.旅游地社会责任对旅游地品牌资产的影响——中介与调节作用机制[J].旅游学刊(6):109-124.
[12] 王晓庄,安晓镜,骆皓爽,等,2018.锚定效应助推国民身心健康:两个现场实验[J].心理学报(8):848-857.
[13] 谢文澜,汪祚军,王霏,等,2013.合作行为的产生机制及影响因素——基于进化心理学视角下的探讨[J].心理科学进展(11):2057-2063.
[14] 杨国枢,文崇一,吴聪贤,等,2006.社会及行为科学研究法(第13版)[M].重庆:重庆大学出版社.
[15] 杨联升,1979.中国社会关系的一个基础——中国思想与制度论集[M].台湾:台湾联经出版社.
[16] 张咏梅,陈钊,2013.基于负债感的激励创新——Y集团的奖励前置制度探索[J].科技进步与对策(14):139-144.
[17] 邹文篪,田青,刘佳,2012.“投桃报李”——互惠理论的组织行为学研究述评[J].心理科学进展(11):1879-1888.
[18] AGGARWAL P,2004.The effects of brand relationship norms on consumer attitudes and behavior[J].Journal of consumer research,31(1):87-101.
[19] AMES D R,FLYNN F J,WEBER E U,2004.It’s the thought that counts:on perceiving how helpers decide to lend a hand[J].Personality and social psychological bulletin,30(4):461-474.
[20] BACA-MOTES K,BROWN A,GNEEZY A,et al.,2013.Commitment and behavior change:evidence from the field[J].Journal of consumer research,39(1):1070-1084.
[21] BLOSE J E,MACK R W,PITTS R E,2015.The influence of message framing on hotel guests’ linen-reuse intentions[J].Cornell hospitality quarterly,56(2):145-154.
[22] BONINI N,HADJICHRISTIDIS C,GRAFFEO M,2018.Green nudging[J].Acta psychologica sinica,50(8):814-826.
[23] CHUNG D J,NRAYANDAS D,2017.Incentives versus reciprocity:insights from a field experiment[J].Journal of marketing research,54(4):511-524.
[24] CIALDINI R B,2013.Influence:the psychology of persuasion[M].New York:Harper Collins Press.
[25] CIALDINI R B,GOLDSTEIN N J,2002.The science and practice of persuasion[J].The cornell hotel and restaurant administration quarterly,43(2):40-50.
[26] DOLAN P,HALLSWORTH M,HALPERN D,et al.,2012.Influencing behaviour:the mindspace way[J].Journal of economic psychology,33(1):264-277.
[27] FAN T,GAO L,STEINHART Y,2020.The small predicts large effect in crowdfunding[J].Journal of consumer research,47(4):544-565.
[28] FLYNN F J,2005.Identity orientations and forms of social exchange in organizations[J].Academy of management review,30(4):737-750.
[29] GOLDSTEIN N J,CIALDINI R B,GRISKEVICIUS V,2008.A room with a viewpoint:using social norms to motivate environmental conservation in hotels[J].Journal of consumer research,35(3):472-482.
[30] GOLDSTEIN N J,GRISKEVICIUS V,CIALDINI R B,2011.Reciprocity by proxy:a novel influence strategy for stimulating cooperation[J].Administrative science quarterly,56(3):441-473.
[31] GOULDNER A W,1960.The norm of reciprocity:a preliminary statement[J].American sociological review,25(2):161-178.
[32] GREENBERG M S,1980.A theory of indebtedness[C]//KENNETH J G,GREENBERG M S,WILLIS R H.In Social Exchange:New Advances in Theory and Research.New York:Plenum Press:3-23.
[33] HAN H,HYUN S S,2018.What influences water conservation and towel reuse practices of hotel guests?[J].Tourism management,64(1):87-97.
[34] HAYS A F,2013.An introduction to mediation,moderation and conditional process analysis:a regression-based approach[M].New York:Guilford Press.
[35] HEYMAN J,ARIELY D,2004.Effort for payment:a tale of two markets[J].Psychological science,15(11):787-793.
[36] HOLLAND R W,HENDRIKS M,AARTS H,2005.Smells likeclean spirit:nonconscious effects of scent on cognition and behavior[J].Psychological science,16(9):689-693.
[37] JAMES J M,BOLSTEIN R,1992.Large monetary incentives and their effect on mail survey response rates[J].Public opinion quarterly,56(4):442-453.
[38] JANISZEWSKI C,WYER J R S,2014.Content and process priming:a review[J].Journal of consumer psychology,24(1):96-118.
[39] JOHNSON E J,GOLDSTEIN D,2003.Do defaults save lives?[J].Science,302(5649):1338-1339.
[40] KIM S B,KIM D Y,2014.The effects of message framing and source credibility on green messages in hotels[J].Cornell hospitality quarterly,55(1):64-75.
[41] KUMAR V,ZHANG X,LUO A,2014.Modeling customer opt-in and opt-out in a permission-based marketing context[J].Journal of marketing research,51(4):403-419.
[42] LINE N D,HANKS L,MIAO L,2018.Image matters:incentivizing green tourism behavior[J].Journal of travel research,57(3):296-309.
[43] MOTHERSBAUGH D L,WILLIAM K F,BEATTY S E,et al.,2012.Disclosure antecedents in an online service context:the role of sensitivity of information[J].Journal of service research,15(1):76-98.
[44] PELOZA J,WHITE K,SHANG J,2013.Good and guilt-free:the role of self-accountability in influencing preferences for products with ethical attributes[J].Journal of marketing,77(1):104-119.
[45] PETERSON R A,2001.On the use of college student in social science research:insights from a second-order meta-analysis[J].Journal of consumer research,28(3):450-461.
[46] PICHERT D,KATSIKOPOULOS K V,2008.Green defaults:information presentation and pro-environmental behavior[J].Journal of environmental psychology,28(4):63-73.
[47] SCHUMANN J H,VON WANGENHEIM F,GROENE N,2014.Targeted online advertising:using reciprocity appeals to increase acceptance among users of free web services[J].Journal of marketing,78(1):59-75.
[48] SERRA-CANTALLOPS A,PEÑA-MIRANDA D D,RAMÓN-CARDONA J,et al.,2018.Progress in research on CSR and the hotel industry (2006—2015)[J].Cornell hospitality quarterly,59(1):15-38.
[49] SHANG J,BASIL D Z,WYMER W,2010.Using social marketing to enhance hotel reuse programs[J].Journal of business research,63(2):166-172.
[50] STRAHILEVITZ M,MYERS J G,1998.Donations to charity as purchase incentives:how well they work may depend on what you are trying to sell[J].Journal of consumer research,24(4):434-446.
[51] SU L,SWANSON S R,2017.The effect of destination social responsibility on tourist environmentally responsible behavior:compared analysis of first-time and repeat tourists[J].Tourism management,60(3):308-321.
[52] SU L,SWANSON S R,2019.Perceived corporate social responsibility’s impact on the well-being and supportive green behaviors of hotel employees:the mediating role of the employee-corporate relationship[J].Tourism management,72(3):437-450.
[53] THALER R H,SUNSTEIN C R,2008.Nudge:improving decisions about health,wealth,and happiness[M].New York:Yale University Press.
[54] THEOTOKIS A,MANGANARI E,2015.The impact of choice architecture on sustainable consumer behavior:the role of guilt[J].Journal of business ethics,131(2):423-437.
[55] THIBAUT J W,KELLEY H H,1959.The social psychology of groups[M].New York:John Wiley and Sons:382-383.
[56] VARGO S L,LUSCH R F,2008.Service-dominant logic:continuing the evolution[J].Journal of the academy of marketing science,36(1):1-10.
[57] WHEELER S C,DEMARREE K G,2009.Multiple mechanisms of prime-to-behavior effects[J].Social and personality psychology compass,3(4):566-581.
[58] WHITE K,PELOZA J,2009.Self-benefit versus other-benefit marketing appeals:their effectiveness in generating charitable support[J].Journal of marketing,73(4):109-124.
[59] WIRTZ J,MATTILA A S,2004.Consumer responses to compensation,speed of recovery and apology after a service failure[J].International journal of service industry management,15(2):150-166.
[60] ZHAO X,LYNCH J G,CHEN Q,2010.Reconsidering baron and kenny:myths and truths about mediation analysis[J].Journal of consumer research,37(2):197-206.
[61] ZHANG Y,EPLEY N,2009.Self-centered social exchange:differential use of costs versus benefits in pro-social reciprocity[J].Journal of personality and social psychology,97(5):796-810.

合作何以共赢?酒店合作策略助推顾客绿色消费意愿以小拨大效应研究

How to Win-Win Cooperation?The Small Predicts Large Effect of Hotel's Cooperation Strategy in Nudging Customers' Green Consumption Intentions

PDF (PC)

赞

可视化

摘要/Abstract

引用本文

使用本文

参考文献

相关文章 1

Metrics

本文评价

推荐阅读 0